It’s only a few weeks until April 16, when Sheffield’s little ones and their parents find out which primary school they will start at for Y1 in September 2026.
And while all parents only want their children to go to the best school they can, there will inevitably be primaries where pupils do not cope well in exams.
Every year, the Department for Education releases the average scores each school earned in its SATs - the exams pupils take at the end of Y6.
But the result most households look at is how pupils met the DfE’s 'scaled expected standard', essentially meaning whether they scored at least half marks in reading, writing and maths - as well as the ‘higher standard’, for pupils scoring top marks in all three.
These are the schools that posted the worst results in Sheffield for the 2024/25 academic year.
However, looking closer, inspectors from Ofsted almost universally are ready to compliment each of the schools below for having high ambitions and expectations of pupils. How that translates into results is where they struggle.
It includes St Patrick Catholic Voluntary Academy, where, in 2025, approximately just three pupils hit the expected standard for reading, writing and maths. It comes after a turbulent few years where the school was branded Inadequate in 2024. However, in a recent visit in 2026, the school was told it was on track for better days.

1. St Patrick's Catholic Voluntary Academy
St Patrick's Catholic Voluntary Academy was sent reeling in 2024 by a scathing Ofsted report, which branded it Inadequate and criticised it for not having "high enough expectations" for pupils. Much of its woes were accredited to having weak leadership and large number of new staff. Ofsted published a new report in January 2026 saying that many areas of school life are back on track. However, its SATs results in 2025 were sadly the weakest in Sheffield, where just eight per cent of its 40 eligible pupils - meaning approximately only three children - were achieving the expected standard for reading, writing and maths. No pupils achieved at a higher standard. May there be better days in store for this once 'Good' rated school. Photo: Google Images

2. Fox Hill Primary
Inspectors were complimentary to Fox Hill Primary school following a visit in January 2025, where it was rated Good overall. The watchdog wrote: "The school is highly nurturing and supportive of pupils... Dedicated staff are deeply committed to serving their pupils, families and community." Sadly, they added: "The school has high expectations for pupils’ achievement, but these are not always realised." Fox Hill posted the second worst performance at its SATs in 2025, where 13 per cent of its 39 eligible pupils achieved the expected standard in reading, writing and maths. No pupils achieved the higher standard. | Google Maps

3. Beck Primary School
Beck Primary School was last inspected in late 2024, where it was rated Good overall and described as "a special and welcoming school where pupils are happy" that "truly lies at the heart of its community" and has "high expectations for pupils." Sadly, inspectors noted that data shows pupils leaving KS2 do not attain well in the face of "significant challenges in behaviour and attendance," particularly after lockdown. In 2025, the school posted the third worst performance in Sheffield, with 30 per cent of its 91 eligible pupils achieving the expected standard in reading, writing and maths. One per cent of pupils achieved the higher standard. | Google Maps

4. St Joseph's Catholic Primary Academy, St Jospeh's Road, Handsworth
St Joseph's Catholic Primary Academy, in Handsworth, was last inspected in March 2024 where it was rated Good in all areas and called a "warm and welcoming school" where pupils are "polite, courteous, and speak to adults with maturity and curiosity." It added that leaders have "high expectations for pupils... most of the time, pupils meet these expectations." In 2025, the school posted the fourth worst performance in Sheffield, with 30 per cent of its 30 eligible pupils achieving the expected standard in reading, writing and maths. No pupils achieved the higher standard. | Google Maps
