It’s only a few weeks until April 16, when Sheffield’s little ones and their parents find out which primary school they will start at for Y1 in September 2026.
And while all parents only want their children to go to the best school they can, there will inevitably be primaries where pupils do not cope well in exams.
Every year, the Department for Education releases the average scores each school earned in its SATs - the exams pupils take at the end of Y6.
But the result most households look at is how pupils met the DfE’s 'scaled expected standard', essentially meaning whether they scored at least half marks in reading, writing and maths - as well as the ‘higher standard’, for pupils scoring top marks in all three.
These are the schools that posted the worst results in Sheffield for the 2024/25 academic year.
However, looking closer, inspectors from Ofsted almost universally are ready to compliment each of the schools below for having high ambitions and expectations of pupils. How that translates into results is where they struggle.
It includes St Patrick Catholic Voluntary Academy, where, in 2025, approximately just three pupils hit the expected standard for reading, writing and maths. It comes after a turbulent few years where the school was branded Inadequate in 2024. However, in a recent visit in 2026, the school was told it was on track for better days.

5. Brigantia Hill Fort Academy, formerly Concord Junior Academy
'Concord Junior Academy' has not been inspected since it relaunched as Brigantia Hill Fort Academy in August 2025. Prior to this, its last visit was in July 2023, where it climbed out of its former Requires Improvement rating up to 'Good' standing. Inspectors wrote: "Leaders have high ambitions for pupils." In 2025, the school posted the fifth worst performance, with 31 per cent of its 42 eligible pupils achieving the expected standard in reading, writing and maths. Five per cent of pupils achieved the higher standard. | Google Maps Photo: Alastair Ulke

6. Emmaus Catholic and CofE Primary School
Emmaus Catholic and CofE Primary School was last inspected in late 2023, where it shook off a Requires Improvement rating and was graded Good in all areas. Ofsted wrote: "The pupils of Emmaus Catholic and CofE Primary School enjoy coming to school. They are happy and safe. Pupils behave well in lessons, around the school and at playtimes. The school has high expectations for what pupils can achieve." In 2025, the school posted the sixth worst performance results in Sheffield, with 33 per cent of its 46 eligible pupils achieving the expected in reading, writing and maths. No pupils achieved the higher standard. | Google Maps Photo: Google

7. Hatfield Academy
Hatfield Academy was last inspected in May 2023, where it shook off a Requires Improvement rating and was graded Good. Inspectors said pupils were "kind, keen to attend school and keen to talk about what they have learned." In 2025, Hatfield posted the seventh worst SATs results in Sheffield, with 35 per cent of its 55 eligible pupils. No pupils achieved the higher standard. | Google Maps

8. Norfolk Community Primary School
Norfolk Community Primary School was last inspected in June 2022, where it maintained its Good rating. Ofsted wrote: "Pupils are keen to learn and do well at school. They behave well in lessons and around the school. Pupils have high aspirations for the roles they wish to lead later in life... However, curriculum thinking does not fully support pupils to achieve ambitious end points in all subjects." In 2025, Norfolk Community Primary posted the eighth worst SATs results in Sheffield, with 36 per cent of its 59 eligible pupils achieving the expected standard in reading, writing and maths. Two per cent of pupils achieved the higher standard. | Google Maps


