This past year saw huge changes in how schools are graded by the education watchdog.
A new “tougher” system was implemented five years ago, but, in September 2024, inspectors no longer handed out one-word judgements for schools.
It’s shaken up how schools are graded when Ofsted comes calling, and whether the new system is tougher or more understanding is yet to be seen - especially as the system will be replaced again this November with a broader ‘report card’ system.
However, that didn’t stop inspectors making their rounds, and several schools in Sheffield are ending their summer term with a different rating than what they started with in September 2024.
They include success stories like Royd Nursery & infant School going from strength to strength and earning ‘Outstanding’ in several areas in October 2024.
There were also several shocks in store, such as at St Patrick’s Catholic Voluntary ACademy, which was hit with an ‘Inadequate’ report in 2024.
Here are the schools in Sheffield that saw a drastic change in their reports in the 2024/25 academic year - for better and worse.

9. Dore Primary School - Good in all areas, down from a 10-year-old Outstanding rating
Dore Primary School received its first Ofsted inspection in 10 years. It lost its Outstanding status from 2015, but the report in May 2025 rated it 'Good' in all areas. The report reads: "Pupils are proud and happy to attend Dore Primary School. Leaders and staff have high expectations for pupils. Most pupils achieve well and are ready for the next stage of their education." - https://reports.ofsted.gov.uk/provider/21/132152 | Google

10. Springwood Junior Academy - Good in all areas, down from Outstanding
Springwood Junior Academy was rated Outstanding in 2018, and was rated Good in all areas in a report on July 1. The report was still filled with compliments. It reads: "Pupils enjoy coming to this inclusive and nurturing school. The school ensures that every pupil receives the individual support they need." - https://reports.ofsted.gov.uk/provider/21/142139 | Google Maps

11. Birley Academy - Good in all areas, up from Requires Improvement
The Birley Academy was rated Requires Improvement in May 2023, but earned 'Good in all areas' in July 2025. The report reads: "Leaders have heightened their expectations for pupils’ behaviour and achievement. Most pupils are living up to these expectations." - https://reports.ofsted.gov.uk/provider/23/143963 | Google Maps Photo: Google Maps

12. St Clare Catholic Multi Academy Trust - Good in all areas, down from 11-year-old Outstanding report
St Thomas of Canterbury School, in Chancet Wood Drive, was rated Outstanding in 2014, and was not visited for another 11 years. In July 2025, inspectors rated it 'Good' in all areas, writing: "Pupils thrive in a welcoming and inclusive environment. Strong relationships between staff and pupils foster trust and warmth." - https://reports.ofsted.gov.uk/provider/21/138828 | Google Maps Photo: Google


