This past year saw huge changes in how schools are graded by the education watchdog.
A new “tougher” system was implemented five years ago, but, in September 2024, inspectors no longer handed out one-word judgements for schools.
It’s shaken up how schools are graded when Ofsted comes calling, and whether the new system is tougher or more understanding is yet to be seen - especially as the system will be replaced again this November with a broader ‘report card’ system.
However, that didn’t stop inspectors making their rounds, and several schools in Sheffield are ending their summer term with a different rating than what they started with in September 2024.
They include success stories like Royd Nursery & infant School going from strength to strength and earning ‘Outstanding’ in several areas in October 2024.
There were also several shocks in store, such as at St Patrick’s Catholic Voluntary ACademy, which was hit with an ‘Inadequate’ report in 2024.
Here are the schools in Sheffield that saw a drastic change in their reports in the 2024/25 academic year - for better and worse.

5. Acres Hill Community Primary School, Littledale - Requires Improvement, down from Good
Acres Hill Community Primary School took a tumble in February 2025 when it slipped from Good down to Requires Improvement. Inspectors said: "Pupils are proud of their school and happy to attend. Pupils say, rightly, that their school is an inclusive place to be... The school has high expectations for all pupils’ achievement, but these are not currently realised at the end of key stage 2." - https://reports.ofsted.gov.uk/provider/21/143546 Photo: Google

6. Killamarsh Junior School - No longer rated 'Requires Improvement' in all areas
Killamarsh Junior School is on its way back from a 'Requires Improvement' grade from 2022. A report in March 2025 upgraded its 'Behaviour & Attitudes" and "Leadership & Management" aspects up to Good. The report reads: "At Killamarsh Junior, pupils feel happy and well cared for. It is a friendly and welcoming place. Pupils feel safe... There is still more work to do in ensuring all pupils learn well across all subjects." - https://reports.ofsted.gov.uk/provider/21/112578 Photo: Andrew Roe
![It's been a rough few years for Chaucer School, after it was sent reeling by an 'Inadequate in all areas' report in 2022. The school shook off the rated in April 2025, and is no longer in special measures. Inspectors wrote: “The school has been through a period of significant instability. Leaders have acted effectively to address the core issues... [Pupils] explain that changes, such as in behaviour and pastoral support, help them to feel safe in school."
- https://reports.ofsted.gov.uk/provider/23/138414](https://www.thestar.co.uk/jpim-static/image/2023/10/24/10/chaucer%20school.jpg?crop=4:3&trim=&width=800)
7. Chaucer School - Requires Improvment, up from Inadequate in all areas
It's been a rough few years for Chaucer School, after it was sent reeling by an 'Inadequate in all areas' report in 2022. The school shook off the rated in April 2025, and is no longer in special measures. Inspectors wrote: “The school has been through a period of significant instability. Leaders have acted effectively to address the core issues... [Pupils] explain that changes, such as in behaviour and pastoral support, help them to feel safe in school." - https://reports.ofsted.gov.uk/provider/23/138414 | National World

8. Mundella Primary School - Outstanding in several areas
Mundella Primary School was praised as Outstanding in several areas in its more recent report in April 2025, up from a 'Good in all areas' report in 2020. Inspectors wrote: "The work of the school to recognise the uniqueness of each child is striking. Everyone is valued. Pupils play an active role in the running of their school." - https://reports.ofsted.gov.uk/provider/21/107006 | Google


