'Life is not easy' - Duke of Norfolk responds to criticism over £2.37m taxpayer-funded Sheffield land deal

The Duke of Norfolk has said his borrowings are “in urgent need of repaying” and “life is not as easy you think” in response to criticism of a payout from the taxpayer in a £2.37m land deal in Sheffield.

Tuesday, 7th June 2022, 11:27 am

Edward Fitzalan-Howard wrote to “put the record straight” after Sheffield MP Clive Betts said it was “obscene” he was set to benefit from the sale of brownfield land for much-needed housing in Attercliffe.

In a letter responding to the “disparaging remarks” the duke states he bought the plot in 2000 for another project which failed, before being approached by the council about the housing plan.

He wrote: “Fifteen years later this has finally come to fruition and my borrowings against this land are in urgent need of repaying. Life is not as easy as you think.”

Sign up to our Business newsletter

Edward Fitzalan-Howard, Duke of Norfolk at the State Opening of Parliament. (Photo credit should read CARL COURT/AFP via Getty Images)

Read More

Read More
'Green for go' - The Star launches South Yorkshire Sustainability Awards

He was also stung by Mr Betts questioning whether he ever visited the city,

He wrote: “I take great issue with you that I hardly visit Sheffield. Sheffield is dear to my heart and over the last forty years I come up approximately once a month and we are always trying to do the best for Sheffield's regeneration.

“The Smithywood Business Park is testament to what we have achieved, quite apart from Parkwood and the developments in the middle of the city.”

Sheffield South East MP Clive Betts said it was wrong that aristocrat Edward Fitzalan-Howard should ‘make money for doing nothing, off the hard work of people who have less money than him’.

And he responded positively to Mr Betts’ suggestion he do more to help the city.


In the letter he states he has invited the MP to meet him to discuss “what we should do with our estate in Sheffield for the good of the city going forwards”, adding: “We are always open to ideas and discussions”.

It is copied to his son and heir, Henry Fitzalan-Howard, the Earl of Arundel, and Jeremy Robinson, of estate agent Fowler Sandford, which administers the duke’s assets in Sheffield.

Arundel Castle in Sussex, the duke's family home, dates back to 1067.


In April, Mr Betts responded to news of the Attercliffe land deal saying it was wrong that the duke should “make money for doing nothing, off the hard work of people who have less than him”.

He also suggested he could give the plot to the housing scheme and say “I recognise I have done very, very well over the years and I want to put something back”.

The duke has an estate office on St James’ Street near Sheffield Cathedral and owns more than 100 plots of land and buildings in Sheffield alone, according to the Land Registry.

And he invited him to use his wealth and resources to help “level up” Sheffield in some form.


Edward Fitzalan-Howard lives in Arundel Castle in Sussex. He also owns Framlingham Castle, Bungay Castle, Worksop Manor, Carlton Towers and Norfolk House in London, according to author Nick Hayes.

Author Guy Shrubshole states he owned 46,000 acres of land in 2001. And in 2015 he received £449,166 in taxpayer-funded farm subsidies and £259,605 in single area payments.

The duke has an estate office on St James’ Street near Sheffield Cathedral and owns more than 100 plots of land and buildings in South Yorkshire alone, according to the Land Registry.

As well as buying land Sheffield City Council is set to pay £760,000 towards the refurbishment of former Spartan Steel mill on Attercliffe Road.

His wealth dates back to the 14th century when King Richard II made Thomas Mowbray the first Duke of Norfolk and gave him land, offices and grants.

Mr Betts said previously: “It shows the class system is alive and well. It really is wrong that it should still be the case today.

“If we are going to level up the country, as one of the big landowners he could make a contribution.”

To continue holding the powerful to account and giving people a voice, The Star needs you to subscribe, please