Nativity: The Musical inspired by the 2009 movie on its way to Sheffield

The prospect of filling the famous stage at Sheffield’s iconic Lyceum Theatre is a task that might fill an experienced director with trepidation, let alone a complete first timer.

Keeley Kilby will direct the STOS Theatre C company production of Nativity at the Lyceum.placeholder image
Keeley Kilby will direct the STOS Theatre C company production of Nativity at the Lyceum. | STOS Theatre Company

But add in a cast that includes 48 children and that surely takes the challenge into the realms of theatrical nightmare.

It has to be said, however, that Keeley Kilby seems remarkably relaxed at the idea of stepping up from assistant director duties and making her full directorial debut for Sheffield’s STOS Theatre Company with a production that might make others tremble in anticipation.

Keeley played a memorable Mama Rose in the STOS production of Gypsy.placeholder image
Keeley played a memorable Mama Rose in the STOS production of Gypsy. | STOS Theatre Company

The show is Nativity: The Musical, inspired by the 2009 movie hit about the children of St Bernadette’s School and their attempts to stage a nativity to top the annual show by their rivals at Oakmoor, the posh private school that always takes top honours for their Christmas show.

Things get really complicated when teacher Mr Maddens promises that a top Hollywood producer will come to see the St Bernadette’s show amid the famous ruins of Coventry Cathedral and turn it into a film.

What follows is a crazy race to opening night, supported and hindered by classroom assistant Mr Poppy, a gang of unruly children and a lot of Christmas spirit as Mr Maddens struggles to overcome a broken heart and to make everyone’s Christmas wish come true.

And for Keeley, it really was a matter of feeling she had no alternative when the chance to take on directing duties for the STOS revival at the Lyceum from November 17 to 21 came her way.

Another Lyceum hit for Keeley was Irving Berlin's White Christmas.placeholder image
Another Lyceum hit for Keeley was Irving Berlin's White Christmas. | STOS Theatre Company

“It’s all my daughter Jorja’s fault because Nativity is something she has grown up with, it is one of her favourite films and we watch it no matter what the time of year,” she admits.

“So when STOS chairman Mark Harris spoke to me about directing it, I couldn’t say no because Jorja would have absolutely killed me if I’d turned it down!"

As for the prospect of dealing with the 48 children aged seven to 12 split into two teams as the warring pupils of St Bernadette’s and Oakmoor, Keeley has plenty of professional experience to fall back on - she’s a Family Support Worker with Rotherham Council.

And she also knows from her own past exactly what it’s like to be a child performer.

The red dress says it all - it's Nancy in musical classic Oliver!placeholder image
The red dress says it all - it's Nancy in musical classic Oliver! | STOS Theatre Company

Her first stage appearance for STOS - then known s Sheffield Teachers’ Operatic Society - was at the age of 12 when she was one of the children in a production of Broadway classic The Music Man at Sheffield City Hall in 1989.

And a year later, she was back on stage at the City Hall in possibly the most unusual part of her stage career - playing the young Winston Churchill in musical biography Winnie.

She went on to appear with many of the region’s most popular theatre companies, including Handsworth Operatic Society, Manor Operatic Society, Ellesmere - where she also served as chairman - and Woodesats Musical Theatre Company.

For Nativity: The Musical tickets visit www.sheffieldtheatres.co.uk/whats-on/lyceum

For more information about STOS - including details of how to get involved - visit stos.org.uk

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice