Mixed opinions on new Sheffield Christmas show - as some celebrate event while others say it was “like a wake”

People were divided on the success of the event

Thousands of people took to Sheffield city centre at the weekend for a brand new Christmas show, though not everyone thinks it was worth the trip.

The free, ticketed event at Devonshire Green on Sunday, November 15, was completely sold-out with 4,000 people attending.

Devonshire Green crowdsplaceholder image
Devonshire Green crowds | Iconic Media Group/ Errol Edwards

Food stalls filled out the city park, while Santa made an appearance and was handed a special key by Lord Mayor Andrew Sangar MBE to enter homes without chimneys.

It all led to the big Christmas lights switch-on, with an Abba tribute band getting the crowd to sing-along ahead of the beginning of Christmas

And while the event attracted large crowds, opinions after the fact have been mixed.

Some adored the show, such as Shelly Pickin who said it “was brilliant” and Vicky Winstanley who added: “We loved it.”

Dominic Baker, from Kelham Island, said at the event: “I’d say it has matched our expectations and it’s nice that it’s free as well.”

Meanwhile others held more reserved views, such as Shelley Seemley who responded to a question from The Star on Facebook by writing: “It was okay.

“Food and drink trucks well priced. Entertainment was okay. But think you could do more. Lights not so good.”

Critiques were made about the lights, which were described as simply being fairy lights you’d find in “a pub or a beer garden.”

Leanne, who attended with her husband, 12-year-old daughter and a group of friends, was much stronger in her critique, saying that the event was “like a wake.”

“There were no atmosphere there at all,” she added.

Critiques complained that the actual Christmas lights at Devonshire Green were just fairy lights which you could find "in a pub or beer garden"placeholder image
Critiques complained that the actual Christmas lights at Devonshire Green were just fairy lights which you could find "in a pub or beer garden" | Iconic Media

“Obviously, it was ticketed only so you presume that it was going to be impressive. And they did keep saying ‘we’re going to light up the sky Sheffield’ when ABBA, the tribute band, were on, but they didn’t.

“There was no atmosphere at all - when Santa came on it was just flat.”

She said that she left early to look around the Christmas Market and lights around the city centre.

After the event, Sheffield City Council have published a feedback form letting people share their thoughts to “help improve future events.”

A spokesperson said: “What a fantastic start to the festive season in Sheffield.

“It was wonderful to see Devonshire Green buzzing with festive cheer, great entertainment and happy faces.

“Thank you to everyone who came along and made the day so memorable.”

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice