Heathers: Cult film with superfan following wows audience at Lyceum Theatre, Sheffield

A cult 1980s film with a superfan following did not disappoint the dozens of (in the main) teens who turned up in Sheffield dressed as their favourite characters, last night.

The opening night of a five-day run at the Lyceum Theatre was a sell out yesterday, with the sense of excitement and queues for official merchandise something not seen very often on this scale!

The Cast of Heathers The Musicalplaceholder image
The Cast of Heathers The Musical | Submit

As someone who somehow missed the original Heathers film, starring Christian Slater and Winona Ryder, back in 1989, I felt out of the clique at first.

It was obvious that die-hard fans knew the storyline, and iconic phrases, inside out.

And the way every single scene on stage received the level of applause and cheers you would expect for a finale, it took some getting used to.

But the enthusiasm and love for the characters was infectious and it would have been impossible not to have followed suit.

The cast of Heathers The Musicalplaceholder image
The cast of Heathers The Musical | Submit

But the applause was genuine - the vocal ability of the cast, the high energy, the chemistry... every clap, whoop and cheer was deserved.

Set in Westerberg High School in Ohio, the storyline is based around a group of 17-year-old students and, as was tradition back in the 80s, explores coming of age issues.

But this one comes with a dark twist.

There’s the standard issues you would expect - fitting in, bullying, identity, friendship groups, sex.

But then there’s murder and suicide.

Oddly, despite the story dating back 25 years, it still feels as relevant today as it would have back then.

This isn’t a fluffy, nostalgia filled trip down memory lane, where you remember the fashion and music of yesteryear; it’s the issues in the storyline that grip you - plus some hilarious comedy to keep the mood light despite such dark themes.

Lead role Veronica Sawyer was played on the opening night by understudy May Tether, who was incredible.

Her vocal acrobatics were worthy of top billing and she commanded the stage.

Her chemistry with JD (played by Keelan McAuley) felt authentic and she provided depth to her character, drawing the audience in. She’s a name to watch out for!

The three Heathers - played by Esme Bowdler, Sedona Skye and Daisy Twells - all shone and comical duo Kurt Kelly and Ram Sweeney (played by Ivan Fernandez Gondalez and Jason Battersby) were firm favourites with the superfans (known as CornNuts!)

Laurence O’Keefe and Kevin Murphy’s hit musical adaptation has enjoyed successful runs in Los Angeles and New York, and if its reception in Sheffield is anything to go by, it’s going to be a huge hit here too.

Heathers the Musical runs at the Lyceum Theatre until Saturday October 5.

Tickets can be booked through the Box Office in person, over the phone on 0114 249 6000, or via sheffieldtheatres.co.uk.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice