Sheffield railways: Anger as electric trains to city 'cancelled' amid record sums for London

Campaigners have criticised the ‘cancellation’ of electric trains to Sheffield after a 44-year wait.

Transport minister Heidi Alexander said further electrification “is not affordable right now,” in a speech to the Railway Industry Association.

But, she said, pausing work had allowed government to make commitments elsewhere, including “a record £2·2bn settlement for Transport for London” and allocating more than £20bn to get HS2 to Birmingham.

Electrification of Midland Mainline to Sheffield has been shelved again. Inset: Transport secretary Heidi Alexander.placeholder image
Electrification of Midland Mainline to Sheffield has been shelved again. Inset: Transport secretary Heidi Alexander. | EMR

A spokesperson for the Campaign to Electrify Britain’s Railways said the move would cost nearly £400m of benefits in the Midlands, and lose £70m in already sunk costs, with thousands of supply-chain jobs at stake.

A spokesperson said: “This was the wrong call for the country. Highlighting the record spend for Transport for London just rubs salt into the wound.”

Sheffield is the only major city without electrification.

Sheffield is the only major city without rail electrification.placeholder image
Sheffield is the only major city without rail electrification. | nw

First proposed under the Margaret Thatcher premiership in 1981, it was axed to save money in 2015 and again 2017.

In 2021 transport secretary Grant Schapps told The Star he ‘absolutely, fully’ intended to complete electrification of the Midland Mainline to Sheffield by 2030.

Sheffield South East MP Clive Betts said it was “ridiculous” that spending on electrification to Sheffield had been given up for a “fast train to Birmingham.”

And transport spending was still hugely uneven. In 2017, research showed it was 13 times higher per head in London than in Yorkshire and Humberside.

Mr Betts said: “We were told we would get money for rail when HS2 through Yorkshire was scrapped. But we are getting no benefit at all.

“The north is not getting a fair deal.”

Electrification of the Midland Mainline is not set to reach Sheffield by 2030.placeholder image
Electrification of the Midland Mainline is not set to reach Sheffield by 2030. | emr

A DfT spokesperson insisted electrification had not been cancelled, and money had not been redirected to HS2.

They added: “These claims are not true. We are committed to electrifying and decarbonising our railway, but we need to do this in the most cost-effective way and focus on schemes that make the greatest difference as quickly as possible.

“New intercity trains – which run on both diesel and electric – will soon be introduced on the Midland Mainline, and we continue to keep further electrification of the line under review.”

Electrification currently runs from London to Wigston in Leicestershire.

The DfT says it will enable new bi-mode rolling stock, being introduced by East Midlands Railway, which can run on both diesel and electric, to run on electric traction between St Pancras and Wigston.

The DfT spokesperson said it would provide a “step change in passenger experience.”

They added: “As electrifying the remainder of the route is lower value for money, partly due to rising costs, and partly as a consequence of the substantial electrification that has already been delivered, we are prioritising our funding on other schemes over the Spending Review period.”

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice