Why Sheffield Wednesday should watch out for the 'traps' in their summer recruitment

The Owls are likely to have a new-look squad come the start of next season

Sheffield Wednesday need to be a bit cautious with one part of their summer recruitment.

The Owls have a gigantic rebuilding job after the damage caused over the last 12 to 18 months. Thankfully, that task will be easier than it would have been had they started next season on minus 15 points. With new owners, a CEO, a sporting director, no points deduction and the feelgood factor returning to a fanbase which suffered several hammer blows last season, there is a clean slate to work from.

Over the next three months Wednesday will need to sign numerous players. But there is one trap I hope they don’t fall into. And that is recency bias. Far too many times I have seen players whose contracts are due to expire, or loan players, or injured players, all of a sudden turn into world-beaters at the end of a season. A club then falls into the trap of offering them a new deal only for them to soon return to their old ways. As one manager always used to tell me, players will always return to their (bad) habits, especially when under pressure. A player with a bad injury record will likely return to the treatment room and a goal-shy forward will likely struggle again to hit a barn door with a banjo.

In his brilliant book, How to Win the Premier League, Ian Graham, who worked as Liverpool’s director of research between 2012 and 2023, gave fascinating insight into how the club used data to help their recruitment. Data was not their only tool, they used it alongside other methods, like good old fashioned scouting. But he explained how they were wary about signing streaky players. For example, they would rather sign a striker whose record was steady and consistent season after season than someone who scored more goals in one patch but then might not net for a while. Wednesday have been the victims of that with one player in particular recently.

Football is all about levels. If you want to get promoted from League Two, more often than not, signing players from League One or the Championship will lead to promotion. Wednesday should aim high with their recruitment this summer, without breaking the bank, obviously. And watch out for the traps.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice