Why former Middlesbrough and Bristol City goalkeeper has won number one fight at Sheffield Wednesday

Owls’ goalkeeping department has a new-look this season

Joe Lumley has been handed the responsibility of being Sheffield Wednesday’s number one goalkeeper at the start of the season.

The 31-year-old re-signed on a free transfer from Bristol City this summer, penning a two-year contract. He experienced a short stint at Hillsborough last term, joining on an emergency loan deal during their financial crisis. He only played two games but he clearly made a positive impression and he has spoken about how much he enjoyed it despite it being brief, explaining that he’s jumped at the chance’

The departure of Pierce Charles to Manchester City and Murphy’s Cooper’s loan expiration meant The Owls needed to establish a new-look goalkeeping department. Those exits left them with just young Logan Stretch, 19, who has since joined non-league Buxton on loan.

Three new goalkeepers - Lumley, Ashley Maynard-Brewer and Connal Trueman - have since come in. Lumley has the most experience, particularly in the Championship, with Middlesbrough and Bristol City. Maynard-Brewer has a League One promotion on his CV with Charlton Athletic. Trueman has only played around 70 senior games in his career.

Owls boss Henrik Pedersen was initially reluctant to reveal who would be wearing the gloves for the start of the season before later confirming that Lumley would start between the sticks.

He told The Star: “He is a strong goalkeeper. We have seen what we will face - so many corners, so many free-kicks into the box, so many early crosses into the box - and we have seen how strong he is in this part of the game to help take pressure off us when it is most difficult, so I'm really pleased for him.”

Lumley started in the 1-0 win against Bolton Wanderers in the Carabao Cup first round last Saturday and it will now be his shirt to lose. Trueman was named as the back-up stopper on the bench. Maynard-Brewer has not featured since signing at the end of last month but Pedersen said it was ‘going well’ with him.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice