At Sheffield Wednesday, supporters have seen their fair share of dazzling talents over the decades, but they’ve also endured a number of arrivals who - for one reason or another - never lived up to the excitement that greeted them.
So when we asked Sheffield Star readers on Facebook to name the club’s worst ever signings, the response was passionate and brutally honest. Dozens of names were thrown into the debate, each sparking memories of false dawns, dashed hopes and head-scratching recruitment decisions.
Here’s what a few of you said ...
Karl Hudson: “It’s Jon Beswetherick for me - he looked like he had just landed on the pitch from another planet and didn’t have a clue where he was, let alone what to do. He once got subbed off after about seven minutes and my chant of “We should have played with 10” was born”.
Mark Blyth: “Colin West ... he nearly hit me with a penalty on the Kop once and I was stood three-quarters of the way up.”
Kevin Clarke: “Gilles De Bilde’s got to be up there - legendary on the medic table. A digestive biscuit of a player.”
Mark Richardson: “Jordan Rhodes based on the hype, expectation and investment at the time.”
David Gardner: “Did we actually play to Rhodes strengths. Asking for a friend. Ola Tidman for me .”
Paul Millington: “Jordan Rhodes by a country mile. Followed by Abdi and Van Aken. £18m in those three. Beat that! “

9. Wim Jonk
The Dutch midfielder arrived from PSV in 1998 for about £2.5m, bringing pedigree and technical ability. From 1998 to 2001 he made 69 league appearances and scored five goals - respectable but not enough to lift Wednesday during a turbulent period. | Getty Images

10. Larry May
Larry May joined the Owls in 1987 after prior spells at Leicester and Barnsley. and spent roughly a year at Hillsborough. In 31 league games the central defender scored one goal - a short-term stay that resulted in a modest contribution before his departure. | Owls Talk

11. Ashley Fletcher
On loan from Watford in the 2023–2024 season, Ashley Fletcher was brought in with hopes of adding goals up front. He made around 23 Championship appearances, but failed to score, making the loan widely regarded as a misfire. | Getty Images

12. Kim Olsen
The Danish forward arrived in 2004 but his stay was very brief. In roughly a dozen appearances he failed to find the net and quickly departed and is now remembered as one of the most short-lived and unsuccessful attempts at finding attacking reinforcements. | Getty

