Heavy defeats, rollickings and deep water - the task of rotating new youngsters at Sheffield Wednesday

There’s not a great deal that can be done about Sheffield Wednesday’s lack of squad depth.

The conversation throughout the season has been a common one; that after the summer of discontent, after the inevitability of injuries stripped away a third of the players available, the Owls have battled against the odds. Though not lacking in spirit, they’ve looked tired in parts.

In Saturday’s defeat to Preston North End, their third match in six days, their available squad was limited to 14 senior players. Of the three on the bench, Liam Cooper had trouble walking in the days after back-to-back matches and fellow newbie Nathan Redmond had played only 20 minutes of football since Boxing Day 2023. Ike Ugbo had barely trained following the birth of his child in midweek.

It left six youngsters, all rookies, with a combined Championship experience of 42 minutes between them, 38 of them belonging to Reece Johnson. Henrik Pedersen has previously placed great responsibility in the hands of rookies this season, though with Ernie Weaver and George Brown injured, debate has bubbled on whether the Owls boss would be better served using the available pups to freshen things up.

Weaver is could miss the rest of the season after picking up a foot injury last month. It later required surgery.placeholder image
Weaver is could miss the rest of the season after picking up a foot injury last month. It later required surgery. | Getty Images

Answering those concerns post-match, the Dane spoke passionately to explain that with the likes of Sean Fusire, Gab Otegbayo, Harry Amass, Charlie McNeill and Bailey Cadamarteri in the side it was already a hugely inexperienced second tier outfit. Though the fizz in Wednesday’s performance dropped, they claimed 63% of possession in the second half and lead six to three on shots. Two of the three goals that cost Wednesday the match came from set pieces and the Owls missed a penalty to take the lead with 20 minutes remaining.

Cooper and Redmond had not been passed able to play for more than 15 minutes by the medical staff and Pedersen explained his view that with his side in control of the half there was no panic to throw untried teenagers into a battle with a Championship side that ended the weekend in fifth.

The Star was present at an under-21s game last month that saw the best of the rest travel to Huddersfield Town for experience playing in a stadium up against senior pros such as Jonathan Hogg and Alfie May. Pedersen was there and it’s understood he made his feelings on the performance known to the youngsters who lost 4-1.

There is a great deal of talent among the team names that evening and it would be harsh to accuse the teenagers of flunking their audition for more immediate involvement. It certainly wasn’t an outing that left them banging down the door for Championship minutes.

Sheffield Wednesday’s youngsters pulled off an iconic Carabao Cup win over Leeds United earlier in the season.placeholder image
Sheffield Wednesday’s youngsters pulled off an iconic Carabao Cup win over Leeds United earlier in the season. | Danny Lawson/PA Wire

But there’s little doubt the need for rotation is there and will be more so heading into a midwinter schedule that will see the first team play eight matches in little over a month. There is hope on injury returns, but further issues seem inevitable. And the youngsters, sooner or later, will be asked to perform.

“They will come in more and more,” Pedersen told The Star on his young rookies late last week. “It will be done naturally and there will be more time when one of the young guys will be in the starting 11 and there will be more times when they come into the games. Then they have to jump into the deep water and swim. I am sure the rest of the team will support them so they can have a good experience and grow more and get more game practice.”

Work has taken place behind the scenes to further develop the starlets, who have been propelled into senior squads years ahead of schedule thanks to the mismanagement of the club by outgoing owner Dejphon Chansiri. Individuals have been given their own training plans and one-to-one meetings with Pedersen and other coaches are commonplace.

Speaking ahead of McNeill’s two-goal effort against Preston, the 47-year-old spoke of the example he has set to earn a more prominent role in the team. “Charlie is a good example of how he grows,” he said.

Two-goal Charlie McNeill, pictured after his second goal for Sheffield Wednesday against Preston with captain Barry Bannan.placeholder image
Two-goal Charlie McNeill, pictured after his second goal for Sheffield Wednesday against Preston with captain Barry Bannan.

“How he delivered at Millwall was at the best level I have seen. We have been tough with Gab earlier in the season because there was too much of a difference between when he is good and not good. He has developed from here. We have seen a positive difference.

“A lot of the young guys have grown and they have had game practice in the 21s or in the squad with us. They have developed a lot, but they have to develop because we will have to use them. This is our job, to develop them and bring them to the next level. They will for sure get more game minutes, for sure.”

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice