My five favourite Steel City derbies – From our resident Sheffield Wednesday fan
It’s that time again, where Sheffield comes to a standstill as Wednesday face United in yet another Steel City derby.
It’s a game that dates back to 1890, when The Wednesday welcomed newly-formed Sheffield United to Olive Grove on December 15th. The hosts came away with a 2-1 victory in that friendly, and three years later they played their first competitive fixture - a 1-1 draw.
Fast-forward 131 years and the Owls face the Blades once again, with Wednesday looking for their first victory since 2012. With the game now on the horizon, I thought I’d look back at my five favourite clashes over my lifetime… In chronological order.
All Wednesday Podcast
Interviews, match analysis and behind-the-scenes chat - new episodes every week.
Sheffield Wednesday 2-1 Sheffield United – AET – Nov 1st 2000
It was coming up to my 11th birthday, and Wednesday were facing United for the first time in almost a decade. I was too young to remember the early 90s games, but remember this one vividly.
All the balloons at Hillsborough after all the build up around the game, Des Walker with a bandage on his head - I don’t remember why - and an electric atmosphere in the Worthington Cup. Efan Ekoku bundling home a header in extra time to win it… What a buzz.
Sheffield Wednesday 2-0 Sheffield United – Sep 1st 2002
Lloyd Owusu scoring with his first touch of the game, Shefki Kuqi wrapping things up, with Kevin Pressman putting on an absolute masterclass in goal for Wednesday. Owusu’s ‘Raise The Roof’ celebration was on show in a few school playgrounds after that one.
Sheffield United 1-2 Sheffield Wednesday – Feb 7th 2009
Quite possibly my favourite of them all. I’ll never forget Marcus Tudgay lining up that strike at Bramall Lane. You could almost hear United fans daring him to hit it, and boy did he hit it. Tommy Spurr getting the first was great, but that Tudgay goal to seal a first double in about a century was truly, truly special.
Sheffield United 2-2 Sheffield Wednesday – Oct 16th 2011


After going 2-0 down in the first 20 minutes, everyone of a Wednesday persuasion feared the worst. The final 10 minutes came along and it looked like Gary Megson’s first derby as manager would be ending in defeat. But then Chris O’Grady got one back, and Gary Madine levelled things up a few minutes later. The scenes were unbelievable - it was a draw, but felt like a win.
Sheffield Wednesday 1-0 Sheffield United – Feb 26th 2012
I remember the nerves for this one, they were through the roof. United were second, and struggling to chase down leaders, Charlton Athletic, but were still relatively clear of Wednesday - who’d just lost four in a row. This game changed it all though. Chris O’Grady’s header, Jose Semedo sinking to his knees in celebration as one of the most iconic photos of my generation was taken, and Wednesday moved up third. They were then only a couple of points behind the Blades, and we all know what happened next.