Sheffield Wednesday, buoyed by a red card for Kalvin Phillips early in the second go, gave it everything and put United on their heels for a large section of the game. But it was agonisingly too little and too late as they fell to an 11th defeat on the spin and the earliest confirmation of relegation in EFL history.
That second half offered more derby scrap than the other three put together and for that they can be commended. But a sloppy first couple of minutes built a mountain they were never likely to climb.
Here are our player ratings from Wednesday’s last derby day for a wee while yet.

1. Seny Dieng - 6
Thrown into the mixer on debut. Dealt with a couple of high balls to good effect. Distribution mixed. Good couple of saves late on. | UGC

2. Charlie McNeill - 7
Slotted into a foreign position at right wing-back. Naturally lacked the defensive instincts you'd fancy but provided something out wide - and took his goal magnificently. Off late. | UGC

3. Liam Palmer - 6
Vacated the space Bamford scored through after Ndala's crazy error, but otherwise scrapped hard and showed leadership in an improved second half. | UGC

4. Gabriel Otegbayo - 5
Grew into things. His striding run opened things up for Adaramola's cross and McNeill's goal. Was combative and had a good second half up until he was sent off for a second yellow. | UGC