His touch and curling shot from outside the box was a diamond in the rough as a late penalty awarded against Will Vaulks for handball gave Cardiff a rare home win.
Wednesday had looked good in the first half in moments but failed to sustain their pressure to go to four defeats from four at the outset of the Championship season. Unable to deliver repeat moments of threat, they looked in trouble at the back for too much of a match played out between two average-looking sides.
Here are our player ratings from a concerning result in South Wales.

9. Josh Windass - 7
Got some joy with his pace early doors down the right. Headed a chance over after 10 minutes from a corner and generally offered something in the final third. Provided the touch that allowed Bannan to open up and score. Took too many touches on an effort a few moments later. Remarkably, he led on tackles. | UGC / Getty Images

10. Lee Gregory - 5
Stationed a little deeper than usual, he acted almost as a second 10 but couldn’t quite get into it try as he might. | UGC / Steve Ellis

11. Michael Smith - 5
Making his first start under Xisco, Smith acted as a target man and put himself defensively, making a couple of important interventions. Couldn’t provide any spark despite his effort across the ground. Won a match-high five aerials to his credit. | UGC / Getty Images

12. Will Vaulks - 6
Came on with half an hour or so to go at his former club and looked a man on a mission, trying to push tempo and lost causes. His ball over the top almost allowed Windass to nod home but for an excellent Alnwick save. Gave away the pen - was it a handball? | Getty / UGC

