'It's caught up with them' - Ex-Sheffield Wednesday defender hits out at transfer decisions

Sheffield Wednesday have had to rely on frees and loans to top up their squad this season.

Former Sheffield Wednesday defender Guy Branston has criticised the club for leaning on free transfers and loan signings this season, suggesting it is money they did not need to spend.

After being placed under a three-window transfer fee restriction ban last summer, Wednesday were blocked from bringing in any permanent signings for a transfer fee during last summer’s transfer window and the recent January window.

The Owls, after having their squad butchered last summer, were permitted to bring in just two replacements, signing goalkeeper Ethan Horvath on loan from Cardiff City and Manchester United youngster Harry Amass. The latter joined Wednesday on deadline day after United agreed to cover the finances involved in the deal.

Wednesday later added to their squad in November, bringing in free agents Liam Cooper and Nathan Redmond, and bolstered it again in the mid-season window with five loan signings and the free agent addition of Marvelous Nakamba. However, Wednesday were operating under the terms of a one-in, one-out process, meaning their squad barely increased in size.

The loan deals Wednesday were able to agree were thanks to the parent clubs not requiring a loan fee.

Manager Henrik Pedersen was desperate to add players in January to ease the pressure and load on the existing members of his squad amid the threadbare nature of it. Countless youngsters have had to step up before their time this season and establish themselves as first-team regulars.

However, former Owls centre-back Branston, who played for the club during the 2004/05 campaign, has criticised the club for bringing in players this season, claiming Wednesday’s youngsters may have “shown more heart and fight” than some of the experienced figures.

Branston questions Wednesday’s recruitment

Penning a column for The Football League Paper, Branston said: “Despite a transfer embargo, Wednesday have signed ex-Premier League players on free transfers and spent money on loans. What for? It’s good money after bad.

“The kids would probably have shown more heart and fight than some of the pros. Again, it’s been about living up to the brand and the history, not running the club as it actually is today.

“They’ve been living a lie for years, and it’s caught up with them. That may sound harsh, but it’s why nobody was chomping at the bit to buy the Owls out of administration. Why so few of the so-called bidders were prepared to put their money where their mouth us. Why the takeover eventually collapsed.

“Everybody wants the brand. It’s massive. The football club is unbelievable. The fans are ridiculously good. The city is different class and known around the world.

“But there’s just so much money required to undo decades of neglect that when buyers start looking under the bonnet they realise they don’t have the dough to get it going. That’s why I think relegation is so important.

“It’s an opportunity to get rid of all the elements and all the things they don’t need. To strip costs right back to basics so they can focus on spending money in the right areas. To rebuild the club on a budget that’s realistic.”

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice