As with almost every place in the side, this is a tough one to call. Both sides have split their season between two goalkeepers, with Brad Collins taking the Tykes gloves before Isted and David Stockdale and Cameron Dawson playing the okey-cokey for the Owls. We’ve gone with Isted above Dawson - just - who has been in consistent form and played a starring role in the matches against the Owls.placeholder image
As with almost every place in the side, this is a tough one to call. Both sides have split their season between two goalkeepers, with Brad Collins taking the Tykes gloves before Isted and David Stockdale and Cameron Dawson playing the okey-cokey for the Owls. We’ve gone with Isted above Dawson - just - who has been in consistent form and played a starring role in the matches against the Owls.

Contentious calls and heroes left out - The Star’s Sheffield Wednesday v Barnsley combined XI in pictures

There’s nothing like a ‘Combined XI’ to put the cat among the football fans, is there?

And as Sheffield Wednesday prepare to do battle with Barnsley in the League One play-off final at Wembley on Monday afternoon, we’ve had a go at thrashing out our best line-up from the two sides.

There are a number of close-run things and - in all fairness - we may have a little blue tint to our spectacles where the close calls arise. Besides, Wednesday finished 10 points better off, collected eight more clean sheets, conceded 10 fewer and scored a goal more. That gives them the rub of the green on these calls doesn’t it?

Here’s The Star’s take on what the 11 should be - with form, current fitness and all the rest of it taken into account.

Tin hat on!

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice