Sheffield Wednesday 'aren't quite good enough' to make play-offs suggests former player

English Football League pundit, and former player, Don Goodman, thinks that Sheffield Wednesday’s ‘defensive frailties’ will stop them making a play-off push.

The Owls go into the final eight games of the 2024/25 Championship season in 12th place, and six points separate them from the final play-off place currently occupied by West Bromwich Albion.

A good end to the season could see them sneak into the top six and make a fist of returning to the Premier League next season, but after conceding their 59th goal of the season in the last game against Sheffield United, Goodman thinks that it’s a bridge too far for Danny Röhl’s side.

"It's been a much, much better season for Sheffield Wednesday,” he told Grosvenor Sport. “But they just aren't quite good enough to compete for a play-off spot.

Sheffield Wednesday’s ‘defensive frailties’

"They're a place above Norwich and, in a similar way, have conceded too many goals. Some might point to the amount of injuries that have been suffered at the back but I saw it from the get-go when they were annihilated by Sunderland in the second game of the season. Those defensive frailties have always been there. In order for Wednesday to take that next step and challenge four or five places higher, they will have to sort out those defensive frailties."

The former Wolverhampton Wanderers man went on to add, "In my opinion, the play-offs are between two teams from Boro, Coventry West Brom and Bristol City. The teams below them don't have the ability to put together a run of results to bridge a five or six-point gap.”

Wednesday are back in action this coming weekend when they travel to Cardiff City on Saturday, with Röhl’s men desperate to bounce back from the defeat against the Blades just before the international break.

The Star has a dedicated Sheffield Wednesday WhatsApp Channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click here to join

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice