Ex-Premier League referee weighs in on decision that could've ended Sheffield Wednesday drought

A former Premier League referee has given his view on a decision that could have ended Sheffield Wednesday’s mammoth wait for a penalty.

The Owls were last awarded a spot kick when Marvin Johnson was brought down in the opening minutes of their ‘Hillsborough Miracle’ play-off semi-final win over Peterborough United. Having been given no fewer than 11 penalties in that remarkable 2022/23 campaign, they went a whole season without last season. It means that at the time of publication the Owls have gone 456 days without a penalty.

It has become something of a running joke within the squad and with social media accounts set-up to cheekily highlight just how long the wait has gone on, there have been strong appeals for a spot kick, the latest of which came in their 4-0 hammering of Plymouth Argyle last weekend.

Midfielder Svante Ingelsson was left perplexed after he felt Pilgrims midfielder Adam Forshaw had handled the ball in the area during the first half. Referee Lewis Smith turned down the appeal immediately and ex-top tier official Chris Foy believes he made the correct call.

Foy told Sky Sports: "This clip is a good one from an educational point of view as it shows that, although the ball does hit the arm of the Plymouth Argyle no. 27, not every contact between the ball and the hand/arm is a penalty. The referee correctly judges that the Plymouth player has his hand in a justifiable position, given his action.

"As the ball is played by the attacker and makes contact with the arm of the defender, the referee's positioning allows him to see that the Plymouth player is not trying to make himself bigger by moving his arm away from his body and the claim is rightly waved away."

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice