Consortium member gives reasons why they pulled out of bid to buy Sheffield Wednesday
A lead figure in the consortium that was named preferred bidder to buy Sheffield Wednesday out of administration has given his reasons for their withdrawal from the process.
A consortium made up of three businessmen was named preferred bidder to buy the club by the club’s administrators Begbies Traynor on Christmas Eve, with a detailed due diligence process having played out since then. The consortium have been funding club losses in the period since and also parted with a hefty deposit that granted them exclusivity.


Speaking to a small number of media organisations including The Star on Wednesday lunchtime, consortium member Alsharif Faisal Bin Jamil claimed that their own due diligence within the process meant that their present valuation of the club was significantly lower than the number they bid at - which he said to be some way higher than the £30m threshold required to satisfy the EFL’s administration exit rules and avoid a 15-point penalty heading into next season.
Alsharif said the scale of work required on Hillsborough stadium was a central concern and confirmed the consortium would not be returning with a lower bid.
“The short of it is that we've completed our detailed due diligence of the club,” he said. “We've hired some of the top advisors in the world. The final conclusion that we've arrived to is that the value of the club is significantly lower than the figure that we were mandated and are mandated on via the exclusivity agreement with the administrator.
“Now, I want to be clear, we don't blame the administrator and we don't lay the blame on anyone's feet who is in the process. Maybe people who are out of the process and previously involved in the club, but that's a different matter. The administrator's role is, of course, to find the highest bidder and collect as much of the funds to pay to the creditors as possible.


“But unfortunately, what's gotten lost in this process is that we are at a point where we understand what the value of the club is and it's significantly less than what we have bid. And I know some of you guys have reported loosely on the figure that we've bid. And I can tell you that it's significantly higher than what has been reported.”
Alsharif explained that there was not a great deal of negotiating space in the agreement they made with Begbies Traynor to reduce their offer further in-line with their updated valuation of the club. Asked, given their due diligence, whether he felt it was unlikely another bid from a different group would come in higher than the £30m threshold, he didn’t ‘necessarily discount’ it.
The Stoch group, who were known to have been in the final running for the preferred bidder rights before Christmas, have already signalled their intention to re-engage in the process. The Star understands other bid teams have retained an interest.


Alsharif said: “The terms of the agreement mean that we can negotiate only a very, very small amount down from the price that we've set with them, and that's nowhere near the kind of reduction that needs to happen.
“It's simply not possible. Not to mention the fact that the agreement with the administrator explicitly excludes, you know, anything about the stadium and the costs that are incurred there, and we've only completed our stadium assessment, as I said, you know, extremely recently in the last seven days or so, and, you know, I think everyone here has a very clear idea as to the state that Hillsborough is in, and, yeah, so there's no way to continue the process and get the valuation to the point where it would be even remotely close to what would be a fair deal.”
The consortium had been in a back and forth with the EFL and to some extent the IFR in exchanging information pertinent to whether the bid would be passed fit to take control of the club. There is understood to have been issues that required ironing out to reach that stage - though Alsharif claims the consortium retained a confidence any issues could have been overcome.
“They've been very, very diligent,” he said. “I've been extremely impressed with the EFL and the IFR. They had just some final clarifications and some documents for us to share, and, you know, we were in the process of doing this, but, of course, this train wreck of an epiphany happened on Monday, and I took over everything, basically.”