Barry Bannan's last stand with Sheffield Wednesday - a frightening, painful, perfect imperfection
The 91st minute of Saturday’s game at Ashton Gate witnessed a moment of rare emotion, the view a few minutes later perhaps even more so. Alex Miller reflects on Barry Bannan’s goodbye to Sheffield Wednesday.
It was fitting that as the clock ticked over into injury time and as the number 10 was lifted into the Bristol afternoon, the referee let the scale of the moment rest. Barry Bannan clasped palms and accepted the congratulations of those around him; those in silver and those in red. There was no rushing exchanges of genuine earnest between professionals recognising a walk of genuine gravity.
The level of respect shown for the boy who first drew the attention of a crowd when doing kick-ups as an Albion Rovers ball boy hung heavy in the air. To notice Bristol City supporters rising to applaud the achievements of Bannan’s Wednesday career was enough to recognise the respect the man holds in that division, surely one of its greatest-ever figures.
It was a mood of painful celebration, of communal mourning and of thanks. It was one of respect, the simple vision of a man walking from a field wrapped up in emotions many. Bannan’s last act wearing a Wednesday badge - for here and now at least - delivered a deep sadness above all else, but also of pride, fear and loathing for the downfall that has prompted it. His presence in the side has been a reassuring constant through so many iterations of Sheffield Wednesday; from big-spending Premier League candidates to a subject of slow decline. To soulless stadium relegation to sunny, unimaginable glory. To German revitalisation and now, desperate devastation.


In the last year Bannan was the steady hand on a Wednesday ship that has navigated the stormiest of seas, acting as an intermediary on queries from staff to Bangkok and phoning teammates to dissuade them from moving on. In the early weeks of this season, with support staff stripped to its bare bones, it was Bannan and Liam Palmer that took on extra responsibility. For staff, for fans and for others, there are simple acts of kindness he has carried out that have never made it into public view simply because he didn’t want them to. In many ways he has carried the club on his back in the bleakest of times.
All that takes a toll. There’ll be dissections of his decision in due course and analysis on what on earth is next for the team he has led with such distinction. For the moment, it is to celebrate more than a decade of through-balls and leadership and silent, glorious understandings with Hooper, Fletcher, Windass et al. To think of Sheffield Wednesday successes in recent years is to think of Barry Bannan.
In many ways, Barry Bannan’s final appearance for Sheffield Wednesday was so ill-fitting, a tired and taxing 2-0 defeat three hours from home in a side bleeding out at the foot of the division. It will have hurt him. But in some ways it couldn’t have fitted better. So much of his time at Wednesday has been tough, none more so than its brutal final year. In this season as in that moment, Bannan was left standing in front of all others as the outright star of the show.


After the whistle, as he stood motionless and weeping in front of his public, it was fitting that Palmer was first to console him. The pair lifted silverware together in the shared poster image of their careers but share a bond far beyond football. It was fitting that Liam Cooper arrived second, for years an adversary and for the moment a representative of a wider Championship era in which Bannan was and is a leading man.
It was fitting that he broke from his position to acknowledge Steve Ellis, the long-time Wednesday photographer who snapped Bannan on his first day at Wednesday and snapped Bannan on his last. It was fitting he signalled to his wife in the crowd, the pair having grown into a four to the backdrop of Wednesday, latterly to the soundtrack of Elsie sing-songs. It was fitting that for the afternoon, a Waddle Wonderland was modernised for a player befitting the tune.
The wheels may have finally fallen off but he’s not done. Barring a change in circumstances nobody is to expect, he’ll get one last shot at the promotion he missed out on and he’ll return to Hillsborough soon in a deeper shade of blue. He’ll get a goodbye, if not the one he and we might have dreamed of. Fitting? A decade of Wednesday is seldom perfect, after all. Besides, one rather suspects he’ll get another crack at it all again, next time in a tracksuit.
Painful though it might be, there’s a great case to be made for perfect imperfections. And there were perfect moments along the way; dangling from a Kosovan’s shoulders in Brighton, sun-baked satisfaction at Wembley, grinning from beneath a floppy hat on the way back from Sunderland.
It was his last stand. The wee Scottish man stands alone as the irreplaceable icon of Sheffield Wednesday’s modern era.