His new life, Barnsley switch and that celebration: A chat with ex-Sheffield Wednesday man Sam Winnall

Few people know the rivalry between Sheffield Wednesday and Barnsley as deeply as Sam Winnall. Alex Miller spoke to him ahead of tonight’s Oakwell clash.

It’s fair to say that Sam Winnall has set out on a road less travelled when it comes to the career choices of a retired footballer.

Where in the old days a ex-player might become a landlord or today there is an expectation that players might head into coaching or punditry, the 35-year-old is these days a qualified counsellor and sports psychologist. Winnall balances his work with the Professional Cricketers Association with the establishment of his own practice, providing therapy to athletes across a number of different sports.

He spoke to The Star in a week which will see Wednesday take on Barnsley, the club from which he signed to a flurry of headlines and against whom a famous Owls celebration serves as an iconic moment for the blue side of Sheffield - and as a continued source of rancour for Tykes fans.

More pertinently, the week also saw Manchester United and England legend Wayne Rooney speak on national television about the mental health struggles he faced behind closed doors when at the very top of his game. Mental health, Winnall makes clear, does not discriminate regardless of status, success or wage slip.

Owls players from 2016 enjoying playing back on the Hillsborough pitch pictured are Sam Winnall and Sam Hutchinsonplaceholder image
Owls players from 2016 enjoying playing back on the Hillsborough pitch pictured are Sam Winnall and Sam Hutchinson

“Mental health struggles arise for probably most athletes at some stage during the career, but it also goes to show that it doesn't just happen to the lads that are in League One or League Two or the athletes that may be struggling from a financial perspective,” he said. “It's happening to the absolute top names that are out there as well - they have their struggles. I think that was one of the big reasons why I wanted to go down the route that I went down.

“Mental health issues don't discriminate. They don't pick and choose who they target. It happens to absolutely everybody and anybody at any given stage throughout careers and those transitioning out of the game as well.”

A career of over 100 senior goals ended when Winnall retired from playing in December 2023 at the age of just 32. He dabbled in the media, making a number of appearances as a pundit on Sky Sports’ EFL coverage, but ultimately felt a more impactful future was for him.

A bright student in his school days that undertook A-Levels while juggling his youth career with Wolves, he graduated from Staffordshire University with an MSc Sport and Exercise Psychology in 2025. An MSc research project centred on how strikers navigate competition from teammates, a topic he found himself at the centre of during his time at Wednesday.

That move came in January 2017 to the bitter disappointment of Barnsley supporters who see the Owls as their fiercest rivals. Previously a fan favourite who won League One promotion and an EFL Trophy at Oakwell, the switch came around the time of the funeral of much-loved Tykes background figure Norman Rimmington, which some Reds supporters took as an affront. The announcement of the transfer was ultimately held-off on until the day after Rimmington’s funeral had taken place.

Sam Winnall helped Barnsley win promotion from League One and the EFL Trophy in 2016. Image: Matthew Ashton/Getty Imagesplaceholder image
Sam Winnall helped Barnsley win promotion from League One and the EFL Trophy in 2016. Image: Matthew Ashton/Getty Images

The former Owls striker has spoken previously about the timing of the transfer and while he has no regrets around any role he played in the deal personally, he agrees there was a sloppiness around how it was handled.

“A lot of what happened was actually well out of my control,” he said. “And I think you look back with not so much regrets from what I can control, but more so just wishing it could have happened at a different time, if I'm going to be totally honest.

“At that time I probably didn't realise how big the rivalry was, being from somebody that didn't come from Yorkshire. There were a lot of things that went on behind closed doors that have never been disclosed. It was sloppy in how it was dealt with from all parties and I think there could have been a far more professional way of dealing with it.

“And I look back on it with fond memories, actually, because I think it was a transfer that brought me a few difficulties but I came through it and came out the other side. I grew a level of resilience with what had happened. I don't look back on it with any regrets of how I acted personally.

“People do move between rival clubs. Mine was obviously at a lower level but look at Sol Campbell, Carlos Tevez, it’s football. But I do definitely look back and think it could have been done more professionally.”

A tense Oakwell return came only a few weeks after the transfer and amid a fierce response from the Barnsley public, which had been fanned partly by comments made by former Tykes teammates in the media. On the bus on the way to the game amid a great focus on Winnall, Barry Bannan had asked him whether he was likely to celebrate if he scored.

GOAL....Owls goal from Sam Winnallplaceholder image
GOAL....Owls goal from Sam Winnall | Steve Ellis

After a predictably hostile reception and loud boos from the home support throughout the game, the forward put Wednesday ahead on the 50th minute and celebrated with gusto, charging down the touchline in front of the Tykes support. A famous image captures the scene, with a Barnsley fan having thrown a Peppa Pig soft toy onto the field in protest. Angus MacDonald equalised late in the game to claim a 1-1 draw.

“It's probably been my most asked question since I've retired,” he said when asked about the celebration. “And do you know what? I look back and if I could have the chance again, I'd do exactly the same.

“That's because it had been quite a difficult time. I'd had quite a lot of stick from different fans and even some former teammates that had spoken about me in the press. I felt a little bit let down by that. I will say this, it was never meant to kind of upset or create any kind of animosity towards any of the Barnsley fans at all.

“It was more me letting out a frustration of not being able to say my side of what had happened in the transfer and dealing with all of the scrutiny that I got through social media. I think it was a relief more than anything to actually prove that even though there'd been so much being said about me, I can still perform and I can still do my job as a striker and put the ball in the back of the net.

“The Wednesday fans really backed me. I think that day there was over 5,000 Wednesday fans behind the goal and the whole game, all you could hear was them singing my name. I look back on that day and it raises the hairs on the back of my neck remembering that.”

placeholder image
Steve Ellis

He looks back at his time in S6 as one of highs and lows - and regards the ‘incredible’ support he received from Owls fans as a career highlight. Some of his very closest friendships in football were forged during his time with the club and he remains in touch with a number of Wednesday figures, some of whom he reunited with at a feted charity weekend at Hillsborough in May.

His work now covers both performance and mental health and wellbeing. It’s clear he’s passionate about his new life and that he sees the sporting world changing to better acknowledge the benefits of professional assistance.

He said: “I do think the landscape is starting to change within how much psychological support there is out there, but when I was playing I don't think it was something that I considered enough,” he said.

“I did have spells of working with different therapists throughout my career and I felt as if I hugely benefited from that but I do think it's something I should have probably explored more and that I could probably have been a bit more open-minded to. I just think that with my generation of players, it wasn't something that was spoken about. I do think the landscape is changing.

“I think the actual stigma behind it is starting to change as well now. People higher up in the game, managers, coaches, the people that make the decisions, I think they're starting to see the benefits of having somebody around the team. It feels as if it's going in the right direction and it feels as if now more sports people and athletes are starting to access the support.”

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice