The game has been immortalised as one of the most controversial games in the competition's long history. A quarter-final between the two sides was locked at 1-1 when Alan Kelly, the United goalkeeper, put the ball out for injured striker Lee Morris to receive treatment. Arsenal midfielder Ray Parlour attempted to return it to United from the resulting throw-in, but Gunners striker Kanu raced onto the loose ball and squared for an unmarked Marc Overmars to tap home. Cue bedlam.
Incensed United players surrounded the referee and confronted Overmars and Kanu. Then-Blades boss Steve Bruce briefly attempted to take his side off the pitch. But the goal stood, indecent but not illegal, and play eventually continued, with Arsenal leading 2-1 and deciding not to do the decent thing and let the Blades score an equaliser to chalk off the illegitimate strike.
After the game Arsenal did offer a replay - which curiously took place at Highbury rather than Bramall Lane - and the second game again finished 2-1 to Arsenal, booking their place in the semi-finals of the competition. At the time Bruce described the goal as “perhaps the most sickening moment of my entire career. That goal I will never forget as long as I live”.
United’s squad from that day have all long retired from playing, with some going on to have varied careers. But what happened to them in the quarter-century since, with one sadly no longer with us?

5. Wayne Quinn
An academy product plucked from his native Truro, Quinn impressed on the left flank before making a big move to Bobby Robson’s Newcastle United. He later returned to the Blades on loan and also played for West Ham before retiring and moving back to the south coast, where he pursued an interest in theatre with the registered arts charity Kidz R Us | Getty Images

6. Graham Stuart
Fondly remembered as a legend at Everton, Stuart also played for Chelsea before arriving at Bramall Lane and had a long spell at Charlton after leaving the Lane. He moved into the media side of football after retiring and has also done some matchday hosting work for the Toffees at Goodison Park | Getty Images

7. Ian Hamilton
The midfielder made over 500 appearances in his professional career and worked as an IT business development manager after hanging up his boots. His death, at the age of just 55, was announced in September 2023 by one of his former clubs, West Brom, with the Blades paying tribute to one of their old boys | Getty Images

8. Curtis Woodhouse
Another Blades academy product who made a big move to the Premier League, Woodhouse shocked the football world by announcing his retirement to pursue a career in boxing – something he had always had an interest in, going back to his time at Bramall Lane. He won, and defended, a light-welterweight title before moving into management at non-league level around Yorkshire. Also involved in helping younger boxers alongside airing his often-outspoken views on Twitter | Getty

