A sensible opening suggestion from Darren Smith, although the now 37-year-old did have a spell at Bramall Lane after coming through the ranks and made one sub appearance. Chris Wilder did try to sign him again a few years back but it didn’t come off. “Always seemed a solid backs to the wall defender at the Lane,” said Darren. “I think we'd have liked him.”placeholder image
A sensible opening suggestion from Darren Smith, although the now 37-year-old did have a spell at Bramall Lane after coming through the ranks and made one sub appearance. Chris Wilder did try to sign him again a few years back but it didn’t come off. “Always seemed a solid backs to the wall defender at the Lane,” said Darren. “I think we'd have liked him.” | Getty Images

The most Sheffield United players who never played for the Blades; inc Sheffield Wednesday man and ex-Leeds: gallery

We asked Unitedites to come up with the most ‘Sheffield United’ players to have never actually played for the Blades, and the responses were fascinating

Over the decades at Bramall Lane a host of Sheffield United players have made themselves cult heroes and fan favourites by showing many of the characteristics that define the football club. But at the same time there have been some plying their trades elsewhere who just have that United ‘feel’ about them.

So, for a bit of international break fun, we put the appeal out to Blades fans to choose the most ‘Sheffield United’ players to have never pulled on the famous red and white stripes - and some of the illuminating responses highlighted exactly what Unitedites want to see from their players. From World Cup winners to former Leeds men and even a current Wednesday man, here are some of the suggestions...

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice