Strange refereeing, two stand-out performers, patronising commentary and a new secret weapon - SEVEN big talking points from Sheffield United's defeat to Arsenal

Sheffield United’s hopes of making the FA Cup semi-finals were dashed this afternoon when they were beaten by Arsenal in their semi-final at Bramall Lane.
Watch more of our videos on Shots! 
and live on Freeview channel 276
Visit Shots! now

But Chris Wilder's side put in a vastly-improved performance against Mikel Arteta’s men, despite a third defeat in four games since the Premier League returned. Here are seven talking points from the game.

Much more like it

This was far and away United's most impressive display since they returned from lockdown, and they can count themselves desperately unfortunate to not at least have taken the game to extra time. Their performance was still disjointed in some areas and was not as free-flowing as it has been at times this season, but despite another defeat there are at least signs that things are moving in the right direction

Two key men

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Oli McBurnie was excellent upfront, despite some unbelievable fan criticism in the days building up to the game, while Sander Berge put in one of his most commanding performances in a Blades shirt since his move in January. The pair have certainly been no worse, on average, than most in red and white since the restart, but their hefty transfer fees seem to eliminate any perspective. Both are still young and new to the Premier League and, although £20m and £22m are huge sums for Sheffield United, it is small fry compared to the rest of the division. Proven players at this level are largely out of United's reach - but in Berge and McBurnie, they appear to have two good bets for the years to come.

That commentary…

Bring back Sky Sports. Darren Fletcher and Steve McManaman seemed to spend more time focusing on Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang - who wasn't even on the pitch - than anything going on on the field while United were pressing for an equaliser. The pair laughed when Granit Xhaha fell over his own feet and won a free-kick, before McManaman talked about his embarrassment when a United player was fouled. The tone of the commentary appeared a little patronising towards United at some points - at least one of the few benefits of being in the EFL was the excellent, knowledgeable commentary and punditry that seems to be lacking in some quarters in the Premier League.

Sheffield United players react after Dani Ceballos of Arsenal scored the winner (Photo by Oli Scarff/Pool via Getty Images)Sheffield United players react after Dani Ceballos of Arsenal scored the winner (Photo by Oli Scarff/Pool via Getty Images)
Sheffield United players react after Dani Ceballos of Arsenal scored the winner (Photo by Oli Scarff/Pool via Getty Images)

A new weapon?

United have gained points and plaudits alike for their style of football under Chris Wilder but against Arsenal, a possible new weapon emerged - Jack Robinson's long-throw. No, United are unlikely to suddenly become Stoke City II and play for throw-ins so they can launch it into the box. But today, with McBurnie winning everything in the air, it became another string to their bow and might be something that we see utilised more while Robinson deputies for Jack O'Connell

What if…

Imagine United, during the spells they were on top of Arsenal and especially after getting back to 1-1 and pressing for a late winner, roared on by 29,000 Blades fans at Bramall Lane? We'll never know, of course, but it's hard to imagine that it wouldn't have had even a chance of influencing the outcome. Of course, the game was played behind closed doors and the reasons why are well documented. But behind-closed-doors football seems to have affected United more than most other clubs and it's difficult not to speculate where their FA Cup adventure may have ended if Covid-19 had not hit.

Oli McBurnie's reaction at the final whistle says it all as Sheffield United are knocked out of the FA Cup by Arsenal  (Photo by OLI SCARFF/POOL/AFP via Getty Images)Oli McBurnie's reaction at the final whistle says it all as Sheffield United are knocked out of the FA Cup by Arsenal  (Photo by OLI SCARFF/POOL/AFP via Getty Images)
Oli McBurnie's reaction at the final whistle says it all as Sheffield United are knocked out of the FA Cup by Arsenal (Photo by OLI SCARFF/POOL/AFP via Getty Images)

The man in the middle

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Staggeringly, BT Sport's Peter Walton's revelation - something along the lines of 'a foul in the penalty box is a penalty' - wasn't the most remarkable refereeing performance today. Step forward Paul Tierney, whose highlights included stopping the game so a player who was already off the field could be treated and penalising John Fleck for winning a header, after noticing that the ball had bounced in United's favour and they were about to start an attack. For the penalty, there was contact but it was soft and although I am not suggesting Tierney has some kind of anti-United agenda, his competence deserves questioning. As does the decision to give him this game not long after he, as the VAR, didn't allow United's goal at Aston Villa that was clearly over the line.

Back at Bramall Lane

After three successive away games thanks to a quirk of the fixture list, the Blades were back on familiar territory and what a magnificent occasion it would have been, both for the club and the city of Sheffield, if the game had been played as planned. It wasn't to be, but there are certainly positive signs ahead of Thursday's mouthwatering clash against Jose Mourinho's Tottenham Hotspur back in S2.

Referee Paul Tierney looks on during the English FA Cup quarter-final football match between Sheffield United and Arsenal at Bramall Lane (Photo by ANDREW BOYERS/POOL/AFP via Getty Images)Referee Paul Tierney looks on during the English FA Cup quarter-final football match between Sheffield United and Arsenal at Bramall Lane (Photo by ANDREW BOYERS/POOL/AFP via Getty Images)
Referee Paul Tierney looks on during the English FA Cup quarter-final football match between Sheffield United and Arsenal at Bramall Lane (Photo by ANDREW BOYERS/POOL/AFP via Getty Images)

An important message:

In order for us to continue to provide high quality and trusted local news, please consider a subscription to The Star by going to thestar.co.uk/subscriptions

The coronavirus lockdown is having a major impact on many of our local advertisers - and consequently the advertising that we receive. That means we are more reliant than ever on you helping us to provide you with news and information.

Our journalists are highly trained and our content is independently regulated by IPSO to some of the most rigorous standards in the world. But being your eyes and ears comes at a price. So we need your support more than ever to buy our newspapers and subscribe to our website during this crisis.

Stay safe and take care. Thank you. Danny.

Comment Guidelines

National World encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.