Sheffield United turned Sheffield Wednesday cast-offs into Premier League promotion heroes after iconic move 22 years ago

Direct moves between Sheffield United and Sheffield Wednesday remain exceptionally rare, but 22 years ago today the Blades signed two players released by the Owls who would go on to help them into the Premier League.

For rather obvious reasons, players crossing the Sheffield divide remain one of the rarest sights in South Yorkshire football. Only a select number have represented both clubs, never mind moved directly from one side of the city to the other.

The most recent was a few years ago when Max Lowe remained in Sheffield after being released by the Blades, subsequently becoming one of the Owls’ best players. United made a cheeky move for Wednesday starlet Bailey Cadamarteri last year but it was knocked back.

Over the years more players have made the move to S2 from S6 than the other way around, including names such as Owen Morrison, Wilf Rostron and a retired one who calls himself TC but is not fit to lace Tony Currie’s boots.

But the two best known actually signed for the Blades 21 years ago today. Back in 2004 United’s summer transfer activity exploded into life when they signed FOUR players in a single day, including Barry Hayles and Andy Liddell.

But the two more eyebrow-raising arrivals were that of Alan Quinn and Leigh Bromby, who had been released by Wednesday. Then-Blades boss Neil Warnock was never shy of a left-field move but he believed the pair had stagnated at Hillsborough and backed a change of scenery to revive their careers.

"I think Alan and Leigh have been treading water for the last 12 to 18 months," he said at the time. "The change of club will do both of them good and give them the gee-up they need."

History suggests Warnock was right. Both quickly became popular figures at Bramall Lane, helping United win promotion to the Premier League in 2005/06. Quinn, a workmanlike midfielder who could also play wide, even made more history with a goal against Wednesday in that promotion season.

That made him the only player in Sheffield history to score for both teams in a derby, and you can’t imagine that’s a record that will be beaten anytime soon. Not content with signing a pair of ex-Owls, Warnock then signed a third later in 2004 when Derek Geary arrived from Stockport County.

It proved to be more money well spent and Geary’s association with the red and white half of Sheffield continues to this day, in his role as the head of the Blades’ fabled youth academy.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice