Sheffield United’s hopes of finally ending their Wembley curse and winning promotion via the play-offs were dashed in the cruellest of circumstances as Sunderland struck late to seal their place in next season’s Premier League. The Blades went ahead through Tyrese Campbell’s finish and had a second from Harrison Burrows ruled out by VAR.
They had further chances to extend their lead, most notably when sub Andre Brooks went clear but saw two efforts blocked, and that profligacy came back to haunt United as Eliezer Mayenda equalised and then sub Tommy Watson struck the winner with probably his final touch before a summer move to Brighton, to ensure that the Black Cats joined him in next season’s Premier League.
The Blades had been comfortable in the game for so long but they could not make the most of their big moments in the game and paid the price, sealing another miserable journey back from Wembley. Here’s how we rated United’s players...

5. Harrison Burrows - 6.5
A man with good previous memories of this ground after scoring the winner in last season’s EFL Trophy final and he thought he had got on the scoresheet again with a well-struck effort from outside the box, but the celebrations were for nothing as ref Kavanagh had a look at his pitchside monitor after a VAR review and decided that Souza had interfered with play in front of goalkeeper Patterson from an offside position. What a huge moment that turned out to be | John Walton/PA Wire

6. Rhian Brewster - 6
Got the nod over a plethora of options for Wilder down the Blades right but it was from a defensive position that he had a hand in the Blades' opener, nodding away a corner which Hamer raced onto and then found Campbell to do the rest. He had many of a United persuasion - including in the Press box - calling for a penalty when he was wiped out in the box but ref Kavanagh signalled the ball had been won and to be fair, replays showed he was spot on in that assessment. Saw yellow for a mistimed challenge on Mundle before making way later on | Nick Potts/PA Wire

7. Sydie Peck - 6.5
With all the attention on one young player with a big reputation in the Sunderland midfield, Peck was out to prove that he has something about him as well - and he did that for the most part with an industrious display in the middle of the Blades midfield. There were sprinklings of invention, too, including a brilliant pass to send Moore free in the second half of a fearless display on the biggest stage of all. He could do little to stop the move that led to Sunderland's equaliser as they quickly snapped into gear, before making way with a minute or so to go of normal time | Ben Whitley/PA Wire

8. Vinicius Souza - 7
So unfortunate to end up on the losing side. The big Brazilian must have covered close to every inch of the lush green turf here and so often used every ounce of his size, strength and class to just usher a Sunderland man exactly where he wanted him to go, usually without the ball at his feet. | Ben Whitley/PA Wire


