Birmingham draw highlighted a problem for Sheffield United - and they might face hurdles to fix it

Sheffield United earned a respectable point on the opening day of the season against Birmingham City - but their lack of creativity was a worry.

With less than two weeks to go until the summer transfer window closes, it goes without saying that there is currently plenty of uncertainty surrounding Sheffield United.

News that United’s owners are facing a winding-up petition in the High Court today (Wednesday), increasing the risk of the club being handed a 12-point deduction, has rocked the boat less than two weeks into the new season.

United supporters have already expressed plenty of frustration at the club’s hierarchy over how this summer’s transfer window has unfolded so far, with manager Chris Wilder being supplied with only four new signings, including the return of Jaïro Riedewald, who was originally released following the end of last season.

United’s summer recruitment drive has consisted of the free-agent signings of Matt Doherty and Riedewald, alongside season-long loan deals for Kalvin Phillips and Romelle Donovan. Despite making a big-money offer for Leicester City defender Harry Souttar last week, the Blades are yet to pay a transfer fee this summer.

Although United’s chances of re-signing Anel Ahmedhodžić are understood to have faded, marking another blow for Wilder and the fans to stomach, the need to strengthen at centre-back remains. United are desperately short of options in central defence, and Mark McGuinness, who was not in Wilder’s plans only a few weeks ago, now looks set to be granted a stay of execution.

Ideally, United need to bring in two centre-backs before the 11pm deadline on September 1 to give themselves an adequate level of depth and quality. Alongside McGuinness, Japhet Tanganga is the only other centre-back on the Blades’ books with Championship experience.

However, The Star understands that the threat of a points deduction has resulted in at least two potential transfer targets expressing concerns. It is now a factor that will be considered in every deal United attempt to complete between now and the deadline.

It is not just at centre-back that United lack options, either. Gustavo Hamer’s move to Coventry City last week means they desperately need a replacement for him on the left flank.

Callum O’Hare started on the left against Birmingham City in last Saturday’s Championship opener, but he is more effective in central areas, highlighting United’s need to replace Hamer sooner rather than later.

Callum O’Hare struggled to impact proceedings against Birmingham City.placeholder image
Callum O’Hare struggled to impact proceedings against Birmingham City. | Getty Images

Despite not being at his fluent best last season, Hamer still registered 12 assists in the Championship, meaning he created more goals than anyone else in the division. He also scored five himself.

If ever United were in need of a moment of inspiration, the former PEC Zwolle man was often the player to provide it. He was a constant source of creativity and excitement.

It was Hamer’s ability to produce something out of nothing that the Blades missed against Birmingham. In a game that offered very few clear-cut opportunities for either side, United registered just three shots compared to Birmingham’s ten.

Those three attempts carried an xG (expected goals) value of just 0.29, according to statistical specialists Opta, meaning the Blades recorded the lowest xG in the Championship over the opening weekend of the season. In fact, only Swindon Town (0.20) and Rochdale (0.16) recorded lower xG tallies across the whole of the English Football League.

Of course, it is important — and only fair — to highlight that United’s low xG tally did not prevent them from taking something from their opening game of the new Championship campaign. They did enough defensively to earn a point from a game that Wilder said they “definitely” would have lost last season.

Additionally, last Saturday’s clash with Birmingham was the opening game of the season, meaning there is plenty of time for improvement. The Blues also deserve credit for their defensive efforts.

Sheffield United defended well against Birmingham City.placeholder image
Sheffield United defended well against Birmingham City. | Getty Images

However, there is no escaping the fact that United struggled to create chances. With Andre Brooks also having departed Bramall Lane this summer, the Blades have lost two highly influential attackers.

Between them, Brooks and Hamer had a direct hand in 26 of United’s 66 Championship goals last season, meaning they were responsible for almost 40 per cent of the team’s total. Donovan is the only attack-minded player to have been added to the squad so far this summer.

xG is a statistic that often divides opinion and can be interpreted in a variety of ways. However, the naked eye saw just how little United created against Birmingham, with their xG tally reflecting that lack of attacking threat.

Although bringing in attacking reinforcements is just as big a priority as strengthening at centre-back before the window closes, United’s off-field situation is making what was already a difficult task even harder.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice