'My agent lied about me wanting more money, I didn't want to leave Sheffield United' - James Beattie opens up on 2009 exit

James Beattie signed for Sheffield for a fee of £4m in 2007 but left the club in abrupt fashion two years later.

The England international signed for the highest fee ever paid by the Blades at the time and was a rip-roaring success in the red and white before his acrimonious exit in January 2009.

placeholder image

With an incredible record of 34 goals in 57 starts during his first two-year spell at S2 and 12 goals in the first half of the 2008/09 season alone, Beattie looked like he was going to fire his side back to the Premier League, but a breakdown occurred due to an alleged dispute over wages for a new contract.

It was reported that Beattie wanted more money despite having around two years left on his original deal, and he left the club in the middle of the season to sign for Stoke, which was a massive blow for the Blades’ promotion hopes.

Now, the former Southampton striker has set the record straight, explaining how he never wanted to leave Bramall Lane in the first place.

‘I didn’t want to leave Sheffield United in 2009, my agent lied’

Speaking about his surprise move mid-way through the season, Beattie explained: “I didn't want to leave Sheffield United because we were in second and we were going up.

“The representative that I had at the time went to the chairman and said, ‘James is not happy. He wants more money’. I didn't know anything about it.

“Manager Kevin Blackwell has pulled me into the office, and I said, ‘I'm not going anywhere, we're going up’. He understood, but that was that.

“I thought, ‘Why didn't the chairman just come and ask me if it was true?’

“We've spoken about it since, and he said he should have come and spoke to me.”

‘If Beattie was playing - not Fake Beats - we would’ve got promoted ’

Beattie also discussed the reputation of Craig Beattie, who was signed to replace James, saying: “Sheffield United got to the play-off final after I left ( 1-0 loss to Burnley in 2009) and they had signed Craig Beattie. All the lads used to call him ‘Fake Beats’.

“He's a nice lad, Craig. He played in the final and the players say, ‘Well, if Beats was playing, then we'd have gone up’.

‘I have respect for Chris Wilder - one of the only managers to help me at Accrington’

Beattie, who rejoined the club for a year in 2011, also spoke about former Blades boss Chris Wilder’s help during his only spell in management at Accrington Stanley.

“I know Chris. He is a really cool guy and I've got a lot of respect for him because when I was managing Accrington, he was manager of Oxford and he was probably one of the only coaches, along with Russ Wilcox, that helped me or offered help,” Beattie said.

“It was my first managerial job, and Chris was brilliant. We had some good games, but then we had a chat for about an hour after and he was great.

“He knew me obviously as a player. But then, as a manager, he's a really decent fella.”

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice