After losing to Sunderland in the Championship play-off final in May, Chris Wilder was dismissed by the Blades and replaced by former Southampton boss Ruben Selles, who guided Hull City to Championship survival last season. However, needless to say, things didn’t go to plan for the Spaniard. A chaotic offseason saw over a dozen players arrive to bolster the first-team and saw the key first-teamers such as Vinicius Souza, Kieffer Moore and Anel Ahmedhodžić leave Bramall Lane.
Following the major offseason changes, the Blades began to struggle on the pitch as they suffered an early exit at the hands of Birmingham City in the Carabao Cup and suffered five successive league defeats, including a 5-0 drubbing against Ipswich Town at Portman Road, which saw Selles sacked after just months at the helm. Yet, in a bizarre twist of fate, Wilder replaced his successor to return for a third stint at Bramall Lane, but things haven’t gone smoothly for the 58-year-old in his third spell. The club has tasted defeat in six of Wilder’s nine games at the helm, leaving them in 23rd place in the Championship heading into Saturday’s clash with QPR.
Nonetheless, with 32 games remaining in the 2025-26 Championship season, Wilder has the time to steer the Blades clear from the relegation zone, but the likelihood of replicating last year’s 90-point haul and third-place finish looks unlikely at best.
However, while the likes of Harrison Burrows and Gus Hamer have yet to hit the heights of the 2024-25 season, there have been a few bright spots for Wilder’s team. Callum O’Hare has impressed with six-goal contributions in 14 games, Japhet Tanganga and Ben Mee have both been solid at the back and Sam McCallum has enjoyed a strong start to the campaign, featuring at left-back. We’ve asked our readers to share who they think has been the club’s best player this season.

5. Tanganga joined the Blades in the summer after a successful spell at Millwall and has continued to impress in his time at Bramall Lane.
Spencer Foster said: "Tanganga been solid at the back" | Justin Setterfield/Getty Images

6. Following successful spells with Burnley and Brentford, Ben Mee joined Sheffield Utd in the summer as a free agent and has enjoyed a solid start to life at Bramall Lane.
Danny Crookes said: "Mee has been excellent too" | (Image: Bruce Rollinson/PA Wire) Photo: Bruce Rollinson

7. OXFORD, ENGLAND - SEPTEMBER 27: Chris Wilder, Manager of Sheffield United, acknowledges the fans after the team's victory in the Sky Bet Championship match between Oxford United and Sheffield United at Kassam Stadium on September 27, 2025 in Oxford, England. (Photo by Cameron Howard/Getty Images)
John Flower said: "All the players have got to up their game. It seems that they're all filled with self doubt. Come on Wilder ,give them their confidence back." | Getty Images

