"Off it..." - Sheffield United player ratings v West Brom as Blades pay price for profligacy, unbeaten run grinds to halt

Sheffield United player ratings v West Brom as Blades pay price for profligacy, unbeaten run grinds to halt

Sheffield United paid the price for their profligacy in front of goal as their unbeaten run came to a halt at West Bromwich Albion this evening. The Blades travelled to the Hawthorns unbeaten in six games and had three golden first-half chances to go ahead.

But neither Gus Hamer, Patrick Bamford or Tyrese Campbell could take advantage and the Baggies were much more clinical, scoring with their first shot on target to go ahead through Aune Heggebo before Karlan Grant’s thunderous finish doubled their lead.

Here’s how we rated the Blades at the Hawthorns...

Michael Cooper 5

A spectator for much of the first half, apart from a couple of commanding punches as West Brom loaded his penalty area, but he almost suffered a costly slip seven minutes or so before the break when he lost his footing on the turf but just about recovered to stab the ball out for a throw-in.

Left badly exposed for Albion’s first goal and then got a touch on their second as it went off the underside of the bar and in, although it was so thunderously struck by Grant that Cooper probably did well to get anywhere near it.

Later made a good block with his body to keep the deficit at two after Tanganga’s misjudgement

Femi Seriki 5

Two contrasting games in the space of a few days highlighted that Seriki still has some way to go before he is the finished article and it was another tough evening here, with not much joy going forward as he and Brooks were nullified by Albion’s left-hand side

Mark McGuinness 4

Back in the side at the first opportunity after his ankle issue, with Tyler Bindon dropping to the bench despite deputising for the big defender admirably over the last couple of games, and will face question marks over his part in both the Baggies’ goals.

For the first he was caught ball-watching a little as Campbell’s cross picked out Heggebo between McGuinness and Tanganga to finish past Cooper and for the second he lost his footing as the ball went through to Grant, although he may have been clipped by the Baggies man as he turned.

He was good in the air as the Baggies tested the Blades aerially but there were some rocky moments on the deck, including an underhit pass that almost put Seriki in trouble later in the game

Japhet Tanganga 5

Mee’s ongoing absence meant Tanganga continued on the left of defence and, like on Tuesday, he didn’t look his normal composed self, perhaps as a result.

He couldn’t cut out a good cross for the Albion opener and was fortunate to get away with one after a misjudgement of a bouncing ball allowed Albion to send Price free and although Tanganga recovered enough to give the forward a nudge off-balance, he was still indebted to Cooper for bailing him out with a block to keep it 2-0

Harrison Burrows 4

The left-back’s strengths have always laid going forward and this was another tough evening for him defensively - although, in mitigation, he got very little protection from Hamer at times who roamed all over the place from his position on the left wing.

It seemed to affect his decision making too as he made some baffling calls, including taking charge of a loose ball that Cooper was ready to gobble up and just launching the ball forward to absolutely no-one

Andre Brooks 5

Given a chance on the right wing after an eye-catching cameo in midweek but he couldn’t hit the same heights here, apart from a couple of bright moments down the right hand side early on.

The young man got an absolute coating from Cooper and Tanganga when he surrendered possession cheaply and allowed West Brom to counter in the dying moments of the first half and looked a frustrated figure, with just 25 touches of the ball before he came off on the hour mark

Djibril Soumare 5

The loan man had a nightmare of it in the week at home to Norwich but he began to make amends early on with some tenacious work to win the ball back high up the pitch and start a United attack from which Hamer almost broke the deadlock.

He repeated the feat soon after to set up another chance but then showed why his strengths lie in his industry rather than invention when he fashioned a good position to shoot but lashed it over the bar on the angle rather than testing Wildsmith.

He made way just before the hour mark for Arblaster and the Soumare enigma continues, the midfielder still not able to stamp his authority on a game and instead looking like every movement is reactionary rather than controlled

Jairo Riedewald 5

A welcome returnee to the Blades’ starting XI after he missed the Norwich clash with illness but he couldn’t exert his usual control on a frantic game which bounced from end to end without much time for thought in between. Made way for Cannon as United chased a route back into the game

Gus Hamer 4.5

Back in the side from the start and almost marked his recll with an early goal as he got on the end of Campbell’s touch after good work from Soumare, but his well-struck effort was palmed away by Wildsmith who got across well to his left.

He was then almost handed a gift by the ex-Owl as his kick out was intercepted by Hamer, whose headed effort just didn’t make it to goal - it was unclear how much he knew about it as the ball bounced off his forehead but it was almost a memorable moment for the Blades.

He roamed all over the field from his position on the left, which didn’t do Burrows any favours at times when Albion countered, but that is the trade-off with a player of his ability. But it doesn’t always work and after he attempted a little flick to a teammate, when there were none within about 20 yards, Albion countered and stuck a chance away for 2-0. There’s no doubt how good he is but tonight he was off it, and it showed

Patrick Bamford 4.5

Showed some decent signs as he held the ball up well early on and brought teammates into play but will be disappointed not to have put the Blades ahead at a key time, and their profligacy came back to haunt them.

The former Leeds man’s big moment came after Soumare again robbed Diakete in a dangerous position on the edge of his own box and Campbell cleverly fed his strike partner in space, but Bamford seemed to snatch at the effort a little and could only help it into Wildsmith’s grateful grasp. Made way late on for Ings

Tyrese Campbell 5

Could have put the Blades ahead around the half-hour mark when Hamer sent him clear with a lovely bit of vision and pass but the experienced Phillips did well to slow down the United striker, send him onto his weaker foot and then time the block well to prevent the effort testing Wildsmith.

It felt like a big moment at the time as United failed to convert any of their three huge first-half chances and so it proved when West Brom scored with their first and then made the points safe with their second

Subs: Oliver Arblaster

Came on with half an hour or so to go but his lack of match sharpness was evident with a couple of mistimed tackles in the middle of the park

Also used: Chong, Cannon, O’Hare, Ings

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice