No FA Cup reprieve for Sheffield United despite Mansfield Town eligibility drama as Nigel Clough revisits harsh sacking

No FA Cup reprieve for Sheffield United despite Mansfield Town eligibility drama as Nigel Clough revisits harsh sacking

Nigel Clough insisted he took no extra satisfaction from Mansfield Town’s shock victory at Sheffield United yesterday because of his harsh sacking from Bramall Lane more than a decade ago - and explained an overlooked rule change amid suggestions that the Blades could be handed an FA Cup reprieve.

The Blades tumbled out of the competition at the first hurdle after a below-par display saw the League One side triumph 4-3 at Bramall Lane, and book their place in the third round despite something of a Blades fightback from 4-1 down.

It was another memorable cup occasion at Bramall Lane for Clough, who led the Blades to the semi-finals of both the FA Cup and League Cup during his time in charge before being harshly sacked after losing in the League One play-offs back in 2015.

When he arrived the Blades were firmly in a relegation battle but they overcame a terrible season start to finish seventh in the table, ultimately falling short in the play-offs the following campaign after a remarkable 7-6 aggregate semi-final defeat to Swindon Town.

No FA Cup reprieve for Sheffield United despite Mansfield Town eligibility drama as Nigel Clough revisits harsh sacking

And when asked if victory felt a little bit sweeter because of that experience, Clough admitted: “No, it doesn’t. It's too long ago. The only thing is that it reminds us what a brilliant club it is, when we come back.

“Looking back, we thought we did enough to deserve a little bit longer. I said in the press this week, all the owners kept asking us when we first arrived was: ‘Can you keep us out of League Two?’

“That was all they were concerned with. We finished seventh in the league, we got to a semi-final, we got to another semi-final and got to the playoffs. And 18 months earlier, they were concerned about League Two. We felt we’d done enough to earn another six months, and see how we went.”

Clough was also asked to clear up the situation regarding defender Jon Russell, who came off the bench against United having already appeared in the FA Cup earlier this season while at Barnsley.

Ordinarily that would mean he was cup-tied and therefore not permitted to play at Bramall Lane, sparking some question marks over a potential reprieve for the Blades if the Stags were found to have played an ineligible player.

But a new rule implemented this season allows players to represent another club in different rounds of the competition if they have already played for another at an earlier stage.

“Apparently now there's a new rule that, if you play in the earlier rounds, you can still play for two clubs,” said Clough. “We definitely got that cleared! I hope you're not suggesting we've played an ineligible player!

“But yeah, he played for Barnsley. We assumed, when we signed him, that he wouldn’t be eligible. But our secretary is fantastic and she said: ‘No, no ... there's a rule this season where you can play for two clubs.’ And I thought he did really well when he came on.”

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice