Sheffield United #tenyearchallenge: Here's how the Blades' 2009 v 2019 starting teams compare

Another hashtag has taken over our social media channels and this time it's the #tenyearchallenge.

There have been some funny, embarrassing and brilliant flashbacks to 2009, so we thought we'd take a look back at Sheffield United's starting line up from a decade ago. Here's a look at how the Blades have changed from their 2-0 win over Watford in the Championship on 17 January 2009, to last weekend's 1-0 loss to Swansea City.

Sheffield Unitedplaceholder image
Sheffield United
Paddy Kenny was the man between the sticks for United ten years ago but now the task of keeping the opposition at bay has fallen to Dean Henderson.placeholder image
Paddy Kenny was the man between the sticks for United ten years ago but now the task of keeping the opposition at bay has fallen to Dean Henderson.
Matt Kilgallon played for the Blades ten years ago, now Chris Basham is one of the men playing at the back.placeholder image
Matt Kilgallon played for the Blades ten years ago, now Chris Basham is one of the men playing at the back.
John Egan is United's most expensive signing and plays in defence now in place of Chris Morgan who played in the 2009 season.placeholder image
John Egan is United's most expensive signing and plays in defence now in place of Chris Morgan who played in the 2009 season.
Greg Halford was also at the back in the match against Watford in 2009, in 2019 the Blades defence in completed by Jack O'Connell.placeholder image
Greg Halford was also at the back in the match against Watford in 2009, in 2019 the Blades defence in completed by Jack O'Connell.
Academy graduate Kyle Naughton played for the Blades in 2009, in 2019 the full-back responsibilities fall to George Baldock.placeholder image
Academy graduate Kyle Naughton played for the Blades in 2009, in 2019 the full-back responsibilities fall to George Baldock.
Enda Stevens is the man bombing up and down the left wing in 2019, but ten years ago that job fell to Gary Naysmith.placeholder image
Enda Stevens is the man bombing up and down the left wing in 2019, but ten years ago that job fell to Gary Naysmith.
Moving into midfield and John Fleck has replaced Brian Howard.placeholder image
Moving into midfield and John Fleck has replaced Brian Howard.
Joining Fleck at the heart of the Blades midfield now is Oliver Norwood, but in 2009 it was Nick Montgomery.placeholder image
Joining Fleck at the heart of the Blades midfield now is Oliver Norwood, but in 2009 it was Nick Montgomery.
A red-headed midfield maestro must be a requirement for United, with Mark Duffy now in place of Stephen Quinn.placeholder image
A red-headed midfield maestro must be a requirement for United, with Mark Duffy now in place of Stephen Quinn.
David McGoldrick is up top for the Blades where Darius Henderson was ten years before him.placeholder image
David McGoldrick is up top for the Blades where Darius Henderson was ten years before him.
Record breaking Billy Sharp has been at United for a long time, but it was Danny Webber who led the line ten years ago.placeholder image
Record breaking Billy Sharp has been at United for a long time, but it was Danny Webber who led the line ten years ago.
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice