Sheffield United might already be looking to the January transfer window after an excellent start to the 2024/25 campaign. Chris Wilder’s side sit in the automatic promotion places after beating Sheffield Wednesday 1-0 before the international break, and are level on points with Sunderland and two ahead of third-placed Leeds United.
An aggressive January window could see United cement their promotion credentials but while summer recruitment was shrewd, transfers are not a perfect art - and the Blades have had their fair share of mishaps. With that in mind, the Star asked Bramall Lane regulars for their most disappointing signings. Take a look below to see who they picked.

5. John Ebbrell
Pictured here in an Everton shirt because his United career spanned just 45 minutes. He was the club's record signing in 1997 but suffered a debut ankle injury that would eventually end his career. Horribly unfortunate. | Getty Images

6. Robin Olsen
Plucked on loan from AS Roma and seen as quite a coup for United in the Championship, given he was the No.1 with Sweden. Struggled from the start, however, and picked up an ankle injury while on international duty in November. Didn't play again and was recalled the following January. | Getty Images

7. Charlie Goode
Another whose United career barely started before it was over. Goode was shown a straight red on his first start for the Blades, then picked up an injury and was not seen again before his season-long loan ended. Photo: Mike Egerton

8. Michael Higdon
Scored plenty in Scotland and the Netherlands but couldn't replicate that at Bramall Lane in League One. Captained United on his debut in 2014 and scored against Bristol City, but netted only a handful of times for the Blades. Signed two-year deal which was ripped up after 18 months. Photo: Shaun Botterill


