Sheffield United can win and can’t win... Sheffield Wednesday can only win

Alan Biggs on the latest instalment of the Steel City Derby as Sheffield United travel to face Sheffield Wednesday at Hillsborough on Sunday

Sheffield Wednesday know what can happen in a one-off game - they squeezed Leeds United out of the Carabao Cup this season.

Sheffield United know what can happen in a one-off game - they lost last season’s play-off final despite being the better side.

And this, at Hillsborough on Sunday, is certainly a one-off game. More cup tie than league fare.

But no penalties to decide it after a draw and mercifully no replay until Bramall Lane in February.

You can tell how much I love it - not. But I’m guessing many fans in both camps feel the same way. Decidedly more in United’s than Wednesday’s on this occasion.

Winning a derby is THE season for Owls fans with relegation seemingly a long foregone conclusion.

Forget the contention that Barry Bannan would be one of few Wednesday players with a shout of getting into their rivals first choice line-up.

Remember that not one would have got into the Leeds side the Owls kids saw off, albeit on penalties.

Remember also that, incredibly, Wednesday have scored one more league goal than United in a season where, until administration, their players and staff were sweating on being paid.

None of which will be lost on Chris Wilder who has an unbeaten record across six derbies as a manager, winning three.

Or on Henrik Pedersen whose immersion into the city’s social life, as an immensely likeable character, has made him keenly aware that this is far from just another game.

Maybe his predecessor, Danny Rohl, saw it a little more dispassionately. Whatever the reason, clear friction between the German and the Blades boss surrounded last season’s meetings.

There’ll be none of that this time involving the Dane in the home dug-out. He and Wilder have met, like and respect each other.

So there’ll be no repeat of one controversial aspect of the pub sing-songs that, even in victory, were not Wilder’s finest hour.

Besides, his antennae will be twitching to the obvious danger this weekend - clear underdogs versus clear favourites. Or at least that’s the way round it should be, whatever the league table might say.

Consider too the stunning upsurge in mood at S6 following the vanquishing of Dejphon Chansiri and the survival spirit that goes with it.

United can win and can’t win. Wednesday can only win.

That’s the backdrop for the Championship’s bottom two. The reality is more nuanced.

Wilder’s men will feel victory can help catapult them up the table to a position that, but for the managerial madness of last summer, would more truly reflect their stronger squad.

Against that, no Wednesday team in my time, however superior, has been more together as a unit. Most of them pick themselves as the only option and they have risen to justifying that without competition.

And the Owls midfield, outside of events in both boxes, should be a match. Besides Bannan, Svante Ingelsson, Yan Valery, Harry Amass and Sean Fusire have all impressed.

It’s why you can’t discount the inferior squad from pulling off a shock. Neither has obvious match winners in terms of goals.

Then there’s the wild card aspect of new players - Liam Cooper, the Owls first free agent signing, and Patrick Bamford for the Blades. You wouldn’t expect either to run hot from cold - though Bobby Davison and Neill Collins, two instant heroes of United wins at S6, might beg to differ.

Looking at it coldly, United should win. Gus Hamer, if he’s fit to return, would be my favourite to tip it.

Feet to the fire, that would have to be this column’s very hesitant forecast. In part because I tipped a shock home win in last season’s Hillsborough clash and got it wrong.

But the bigger reality is that no result, barring anything convincing for either team, would surprise me in the least.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice