The Steel City derby is one of the biggest and most talked about rivalries in the English football pyramid. It has over 133 years of history and has been played 147 times in total since the first competitive showdown between Sheffield United and Sheffield Wednesday in 1893.
The majority of derby matches have been played in the top two tiers of English football, with only two seasons (1979–80 and 2011–12) featuring both teams in the third tier.
However, despite the long-standing rivalry between the pair, the two clubs have had a monumental crossover down the years. For example, Max Lowe hit the headlines in 2024 when he agreed to move to Sheffield Wednesday after a four-year association with the Blades, which had notably seen him win promotion in 2022/23.
The move added him to a list of players to have crossed the Steel City divide by playing for both the Blades and the Owls. But who else has represented both South Yorkshire giants?
Here we take a look at all of the 23 stars that have played for both teams since 2000, including some that you may well have you may have forgotten about.

21. Carl Robinson
Welsh midfielder Robinson, who has recently worked as a manager in Australia, had brief loan spells at Sheffield Wednesday and Sheffield United in 2003 and 2004 respectively without establishing himself as a regular fixture in the team at either club. | Getty Images

22. Keith Treacy
Republic of Ireland international Treacy joined Sheffield United on a loan deal from Blackburn in 2009 and scored once in 16 Championship appearances. The midfielder also played seven times for Sheffield Wednesday in 2011/12 after joining on loan from Burnley. | Getty Images

23. Dean Windass
Windass is best known for excellent goalscoring stints at Hull City and Bradford City but he did also spend a small part of his career in the Steel City. He played two matches for Sheffield Wednesday during a loan spell in 2001/02 before joining the Blades a year later, scoring six times in 20 appearances during his sole season at Bramall Lane. | Getty Images


