The good, the bad and the ugly as Sheffield United and Sheffield Wednesday hope for a brighter 2026

Alan Biggs reflects on 2025 and looks ahead to 2026 for Sheffield’s two main clubs

Only the word “Sheffield” at the start truly unites the city’s two professional clubs - except for two glaring truths as we head into 2026.

1. Every Blade or Owl would accept that the standing of both these clubs, and the city as a whole, should be much higher.

2. Every Owl or Blade knows that abject club ownership is the reason why currently this is not the case.

It’s the common denominator - whether it be a single individual in one case or any number of them in the other.

Poor ownership is the biggest single thing football has to fix. And it kicks off this New Year column - a personal view of the good, the bad and the ugly of the beautiful game.

The good, the bad and the ugly

The Good: The incoming regulator. At least I hope so. Although, as distinct from events at S6, I don’t believe the controllers of S2 are questionable for business acumen in their own fields, just misguided and needing to take professional advice to plug their limited football knowledge. Even Dejphon Chansiri had a smooth first couple of years. COH Sports have been at the wheel of a car crash in their first 12 months. Projected new ownership at Hillsborough is associated with that. Fingers crossed, couldn’t make it up!

The Bad: See above. Why can’t club investors, often not football people, run the business in the way they created personal wealth - by delegating to specialists in the field? Too much ego and arrogance.

The Ugly: Reckless chasing of the dream. Lack of sustainability plans. Knee-jerk hiring and firing of managers. Again, over to the regulator and plans for regular license testing.

The Good: Fans flexing muscle. And winning for a change. Let there be no mistake, while it was Dejphon Chansiri who ran himself and Sheffield Wednesday aground, it was supporters’ boycotts that finally sunk him. With that example to follow, there’ll be more of this unless the regulator gets there first.

The Bad: VAR. Woe betide the EFL if they adopt the biggest passion-killer the game has ever suffered.

The Ugly: Interminable navel-gazing delays with goal cheers choked in throats. No-one seems willing to address the big question. And it’s not whether VAR has improved accuracy of decision-making (which is highly questionable). It’s simply this: Football is an entertainment industry - has VAR added to the game as a spectacle or damaged it?

The Good: The return of the long throw, the long ball upfield. And admiration for it. Within reason, there is no right or wrong way to play football. And the pretentious possession-based fixation is, well, passing. It can be more effective to have less possession, as many a result proves.

The Bad: Don’t be a fashion-following coach and pretend it is “your philosophy.” Far too many at all levels trying to “be like Pep” and instructing passing from the keeper - when you see even the technically gifted fall foul of doing it.

Lately, 4-2-3-1 has been in vogue nearly everywhere. Full credit to those who operate it well. If not, why not try something different?

The Ugly: Those infuriating tactical time-outs where goalkeepers go down “injured” and, in the words of an old song, “everything stops for tea.” Good to hear that the authorities are addressing measures to stop this practice and the sooner the better.

The Good: Metrics.

The Bad: Metrics.

The Ugly: Metrics

Ticks all three boxes! Good as a measure of performance or player recruitment. But as one measure. Not as a replacement for eyes on the subject. Or intuition. Or judgment of character. The game is insatiably obsessed with data. But as one respected coach told me: “Too much analysis equals paralysis.”

The Good: Sporting directors and recruitment chiefs feeling some heat for bad results. The head coach is no longer the only fall guy.

The Bad: Manager unveilings that preach long-term planning when we all know the truth. But I’d add to that managers affecting undying loyalty to a club - when, again, we all know the truth in the real world.

The Ugly: Hateful outbursts towards managers leaving one club for another. They are only doing what we’d all do if offered a better job.

But we’ll finish on an up.

The Good: For all its faults, interest in football has never been higher, not least in this city. It’s probably why we moan so much - because we care. Attendances are up. The game still captivates us, transports us (as U2’s “Beautiful Day put it) to “that other place.”

Let’s keep it that way.

Happy New Year everyone.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice