Giant: How Pierce Brosnan became Brendan Ingle in new 'Prince' Naseem Hamed film in cinemas now
We are two old-school Star journalists who vividly recall what life was like in the 1990s and had worked for years with Sheffield boxing trainer Brendan Ingle.
Martin Smith and I were sceptical about how the new movie 'Giant' could accurately depict the life and times of Ingle and his protégé Naseem Hamed.


And specifically, we couldn't figure out how on earth Brosnan could become Brendan.
Pierce Brosnan is a veteran actor, best known to the world for his role as James Bond, as well as major appearances in The Thomas Crown Affair, Dante's Peak, and Mrs Doubtfire.
But can anyone really carry off Brendan?
Martin and I were also intrigued by how any actor - in this case, Amir El-Masry - could encapsulate the ego-driven, eccentric world of 1990s superstar boxer Naz.
Last night, in a special viewing at The Light in Sheffield, we got the answers.
The movie had been a full 10 years in the making, confirmed director Rowan Athale, who along with El-Masry, surprised the sparse Sheffield audience by popping up to address them before we settled down to the main event.


"I am so proud to be here, it feels like we have come full circle" El-Masry told us.
He recalled going to the Wincobank gym to meet the Ingle family, while Athale applauded the spectators for fighting their way through wintry conditions to take their seats.
It set the scene for a hugely entertaining yet sometimes disconcerting evening.
Right from the off, we should stress that Martin and I worked around the fringes of Sheffield boxing in that era; we were not full-time boxing writers or embedded with the Ingles.


However, we both enjoyed a fond relationship with Brendan, who, while protective of our personal connection, was always happy to use The Star and other media to further the aims of his fighters and his gym.
It was a neat, if not always cosy, reciprocal arrangement.
We don't pretend to be as knowledgeable as others from that era, not least of all Naz, and Brendan's sons Dominic and John, both of whom are in the opening film credits as consultants.
But we had our own thoughts on the Ingle-Naz partnership that first conquered the world and then fell apart in bitterness and mutual accusations.


So here are our impressions, the good, bad and the ugly.
The Good.
Brosnan WAS Brendan. We didn't think it was possible, but he achieved it. If you knew Brendan, you felt you knew Brosnan.
The trainer's obsession with hard work, dedication, and decency, along with an Irish charm fuelled by a tendency to talk too much, truly hit the mark.
There were three actors who played Hamed.
Brothers Ghaith and Ali Saleh play the featherweight between the ages of seven and 12, while El-Masry portrays the boxer at his peak.


The young actors were thoroughly believable.
El-Masry had to overcome the awkward fact that he is older, taller and bigger than Naz was in his heyday and, let's be fair, even world-class boxers cannot fully emulate the unconventional, flamboyant, and explosive style he unleashed over 37 professional fights.
But despite those challenges, and with only five weeks to train for the fight sequences, the Egyptian-British actor pulled off a cinematic miracle on a par with Brosnan.
The pace of the film is absorbing: there are early warning signs as the Ingle-Hamed relationship begins to unravel, and the audience is encouraged to take a view on the perceived role of Naz's brother Riath in that.
The intensity behind that faltering alliance starts to ratchet up.
The Bad.
Riath and Naz won't like much of this film, we imagine.
Riath is portrayed as a meddler, throwing a spanner in the works. Naz gives the impression of being arrogant and dismissive of Brendan's input into his success. The fighter apparently became lazy in his training.
In real life, Naz, who turns 52 next month, has claimed: "80-90 per cent of the film is just made up" - but that hasn't stopped him watching it four times and attending a promotional event.
“It’s just strange for me to watch a film about my trainer and me – and our relationship – and so much not be covered or true" he reportedly said.
One example of this is the scene where Brendan, a top-deck passenger on a bus, spots a young Naz for the first time.
The speedy lad is giving bullies the slip in a schoolyard, avoid a hiding.
That is apocryphal - an invention that Brendan once told us he'd formed to sell Naz to the public.
Martin and I weren't hugely impressed with the introduction of a "Sheffield Star journalist" who wandered into the gym and stayed the course through the film - her mythical contribution obscuring the work of the respected sports writer Simon Meeks.
And the Frank Warren character (played by Toby Stephens) was a little hard to embrace, too.
But this was a "docudrama" - and liberties were always going to be taken to improve the viewer experience.
The Ugly.
Sheffield is a different place from what it was in the 1970s-90s.
So the brutal and frequent outbursts of racism against Naz, particularly early in the film, make for uncomfortable watching.
The barbs were indeed ugly - but a necessary element to show how Naz, his family and thousands of others had to overcome prejudice in the UK in that period.
At the end, Martin and I trudged out into the Sheffield snow, feeling it had been more than money well spent.
The film had brought back an electrifying part of our journey at The Star, yet it was also a jarring memory of what the culture was like in the city and elsewhere 30-40 years ago.
The performances pulled no punches - much like teak-tough Mexican Marco Antonio Barrera, who effectively ended Naz's fight career and went on to have exactly twice as many fights as the South Yorkshireman.
And the only tragedy last night was that Brendan, who died in 2018, couldn't be sat amongst us watching it.
RIP Brendan. People like you, and Naz, only come this way once.