We don’t want American ideas here

Migrants and refugees
Migrants and refugees
Have your say

Les Arnott’s suggestion that we help real refugees is commendable, but there is a fundamental problem with his recommendation for the use of polygraphs, ie, lie detectors. The fact is they do not work.

This month’s Skeptical Enquirer explains that the scientific community consider it pseudo science which has led to wrong verdicts of guilty and not guilty alike.

One man in America was proven to be a spy after passing the test five times.

Another man committed 49 murders but passed the test, while another man eventually proven innocent of these murders had failed the test.

Perhaps he didn’t look on Google where instructions abound as to how to defeat the test.

So let us not bring America’s unscientific ideas over here, we have enough of our own.


by email