VOTE: Which South Yorks chippy is batter than rest?

Vote: Help us find the best chippy in South Yorkshire.
Vote: Help us find the best chippy in South Yorkshire.
Have your say

THE chips are down – now’s the time to wrap this contest up and vote for the best chippy in South Yorkshire.

You’ve been chipping in for days with your nominations after The Star launched a search to find South Yorkshire’s Best Chippy.

Suggestions have come in for top notch chip shops all around the county – from Barnsley to Balby, Darnall to Doncaster, Manor Top to Mosborough.

And the mouthwatering reasons you gave for choosing your favourites couldn’t be battered.

Early front-runners include Rob’s Fish and Chips in Greenhill, Tony’s in Mosborough, Richmond Fisheries in Richmond, New Cod on the Block at Commonside, Hicks Street Chippy in Shalesmoor, Woodseats Fisheries, Fry Master in Attercliffe, Whitby’s of Catcliffe, and the Castle Chippy in Castle Market.

Nev Furness, aged 72, from Ranmoor Road, said of Hicks Street: “It’s the best fish and chips, and the service is quick.”

Lisa Wright, 48, of Brooklands Crescent, Fulwood, added: “It’s the best around.”

Gilly Carrington, 50, of Greenoak Avenue, Totley Rise, nominated Rob’s.

“Well worth a visit,” she said. “Generous portions, always hot. A taste to die for.”

Maureen Woodcock, 73 of Fulford Place, Darnall, went for Frymaster: “Crispy chips and fish all cooked in beef dripping.”

Ethel Woodley, 71 of College Court, Burngreave, loves Whitby’s. “It’s a long ride on the bus to Catcliffe, but worth it,” she said. “Fish in batter, awesome.”

Kevin Slater, 49, of Delves Road in Hackenthorpe, travels to Mosborough to get his chips from Tony’s. “Best tasting fish and chips in Sheffield,” he reckoned. “Everything is cooked to perfection and it’s always very busy which speaks for itself.”

Laraine Livermore, 58, of Becket Walk, Lowedges, is one of the many fans of Woodseats Fisheries.

She said: “Beautiful white fish, tasty chips. It’s fantastic value and great staff also.”

Annie Coldwell, 91, from Maltravers Crescent, Wybourn, went for the Castle Chippy in Castle Market.

She said: “Good fish and chips and about the cheapest around.”

George Warris, 68, of Auckland Rise, Halfway, agreed: “Chips are brown and tasty. Cod is white and surrounded with tasty batter, not brittle.”

Paul Cross, 49, of Harpenden Drive, Hatfield, went for Rothwells in Doncaster. He said: “It’s a traditional chippy.”

And Anthony Gill, 70, of Rodger Road, Woodhouse, is a fan of the Swallownest Fish Bar.

He says: “The best chips and fish outside Cleethorpes – you should try them.”


Nominations for your favourite chippy will carry over to the voting process – where we now shortlist the 54 you’ve suggested and whittle them down to just six finalists.

The six which receive the most votes will be featured in The Star and online, before our panel of experts make a final decision.

You can vote as many times as you like in the shortlisting process by text or using the entry form printed in paper (Wednesday, February 27, 2013). No photocopies allowed.

Vote for only one of the chip shops nominated and listed below. Get your vote to us by the deadline of Wednesday, March 6, 2013, at 5pm.

Do not enter after this time, or your vote will not be counted but you may still be charged for your text. Details below.

Send your text to 61500 with the word STA (space) CHIPPY (space) then your vote number (01-54) followed by a space then your name house number and postcode.

Texts cost 25p plus your usual network rate. The Editor’s decision is final.

By supplying your telephone number you’re happy to receive SMS messages from Johnston Press and its approved business partners. Johnston Press (or via its agents) and its business partners may contact you about new promotions, products and services. Please add the word EXIT at the end of your message if you do not wish to receive these. Please note, if you should enter after the stated closing date your entry will not be valid but you still may be charged. For quality and training purposes we may monitor communications. SMS service is provided by Velti DR Ltd SE1 8ND - 0207 633 5000. Full terms and conditions are available on request from Promotions or go online at


01 Abbey Friar, Abbeydale Road, Sheffield

02 Admiral, Crookes, Sheffield

03 Admiral, Killamarsh

04 Alverley Fisheries, Balby, Doncaster

05 Arundel Road Fisheries, Chapeltown

06 Brenda’s Traditional Fish and Chips, Earl Way, Moorfoot, Sheffield city centre

07 Broomheads, Crookes, Sheffield

08 Castle Chippy, Castle Market,

Sheffield city centre

09 Cottage Fish Bar, High Street,


10 Crosspool Fish Bar, Crosspool, Sheffield

11 Dale Road Fisheries, Rawmarsh, Rotherham

12 Darnall Fisheries, Main Road, Darnall, Sheffield

13 Darn’s, Summer Lane, Barnsley

14 Derbyshire Lane Fishbar, Sheffield

15 Devonshire Chippy, Devonshire Street, Sheffield city centre

16 Five Star Fish Bar, Crookes, Sheffield

17 Four Lanes, Leppings Lane,

Hillsborough, Sheffield

18 Fry Master, Attercliffe Road, Sheffield

19 Gary’s Fisheries, Barnsley town centre

20 Hicks Street Chippy, Shalesmoor, Sheffield

21 King Cod Fish Bar, Sunnyside, Rotherham

22 King Fishery, Carcroft, Doncaster

23 Listerdale Fish Bar, Brecks, Rotherham

24 Manor Fisheries, Kimberworth, Rotherham

25 Marishells Chippy, Ecclesfield

26 Meadowhead Fish Bar,

Meadowhead, Sheffield

27 New Cod on the Block, Commonside, Sheffield

28 Norwood Fish Bar, Herries Road

29 Ocean Fish Bar, Chesterfield

30 Oceana, Wisewood, Sheffield

31 Pacific Catch, Main Road, Darnall

32 Pete’s Chippy, Main Street,


33 Poseidon, Abbey Lane, Woodseats, Sheffield

34 Ranmoor Friery, Fulwood Road, Sheffield

35 Richmond Fisheries, Richmond Road, Sheffield

36 Rob’s Fish and Chips, Greenhill, Sheffield

37 Robin Hood’s Bay Fish Bar,

Attercliffe Road, Sheffield

38 Rothwell’s, Market Place, Doncaster

39 A Salt n Battered, London Road, Sheffield

40 Sea Fresh Fish Bar, Brinsworth Lane, Brinsworth, Rotherham

41 Stanwood Friery, Stannington, Sheffield

42 Swallownest Fish Bar, High Street, Swallownest

43 Ted’s Chippy, Manor Park Centre, Sheffield

44 Today’s Catch, Southey Green Road, Wadsley Bridge, Sheffield

45 Tony’s Fish and Chips, Chapel Street, Mosborough, Sheffield

46 Trafalgar Fisheries, Trafalgar Road, Wadsley Bridge, Sheffield

47 Two Steps Fisheries, Sharrow Vale Road, Sheffield

48 Union Jack, Chatsworth Road, Chesterfield

49 West End Fisheries, Woodhouse, Sheffield

50 Wheatley’s Fish and Chips, Manor Lane, Sheffield

51 Whitby’s, Poplar Way, Catcliffe, Rotherham

52 Woodseats Fisheries, Chesterfield Road, Woodseats, Sheffield

53 Woody’s Fish and Chips, Barnsley

54 XL Fisheries, Bawtry Road, Wickersley, Rotherham