Footballer’s plane filled with deadly gas before it crashed, air accident investigators reveal

Air accident investigators have said the plane piloted by Crowle man Dave Ibbotson was filled with harmful levels of carbon monoxide before it crashed into the English Channel and killed both him and his passenger, Argentinian footballer Emiliano Sala.

Wednesday, 14th August 2019, 10:43 pm
Updated Wednesday, 14th August 2019, 10:44 pm
A supporter looks at flowers placed in front of a giant portrait of Nantes' Argentinian forward Emilianio Sala before the French L1 football match between FC Nantes and AS Saint Etienne (ASSE) at the La Beaujoire stadium in Nantes, western France on January 30, 2019. - A plane transporting Sala -- who had just been transferred from French team Nantes to Premier League club Cardiff City in a 17-million-euro ($19.3-million) move -- and British pilot Dave Ibbotson vanished from radar around 20 kilometres (12 miles) north of the Channel island of Guernsey on January 21. (Photo by SEBASTIEN SALOM GOMIS / AFP).

The Air Accident Investigation Board (AAIB) said Sala was exposed to harmful levels of carbon monoxide before he was killed and it is likely his pilot was also affected.

Tests on the striker's body found enough evidence of the harmful gas to cause a heart attack, seizure or unconsciousness, and it was ‘likely’ that pilot David Ibbotson was also ‘affected to some extent’ by the gas, they added.

Read More

Read More
Body recovered from plane in English Channel confirmed as Cardiff City footballe...

Sign up to our daily newsletter

The i newsletter cut through the noise

The AAIB said the gas can ‘reduce or inhibit a pilot's ability to fly an aircraft’.

Argentinian footballer Sala signed for Cardiff City from French club Nantes for £15 million on January 18.

Mr Ibbotson, 59, of Crowle, Lincolnshire, flew Sala from Cardiff to Nantes the following day. The return flight - which crashed in the Channel - was on January 21.

Sala's body was recovered on February 6 but Mr Ibbotson has not been located.

The aircraft remains underwater off the coast of Guernsey after an attempt to recover it was hampered by bad weather.

Mr Ibbotson's widow Nora believes that trying to safely bring the aircraft up from the seabed could be a way to find some answers about what happened.

She also told Sky News that carbon monoxide potentially having any part in what happened had ‘never even occurred to me, it was all about the weather and things like that’.

She described the development as ‘a massive shock’, telling Sky News: "It makes a big difference because they've been poisoned, they have no idea it's a lethal gas.

"You can't smell it. You can't see it. It's lethal, they wouldn't have known.

"So it's nothing to do with the flying or anything like that, it's down to the aircraft."

Mrs Ibbotson said she must now wait for answers, adding: "It's not going to change my situation, I've lost a husband, a father, a grandfather. Nothing can repay that, and change it."

Piston engine aircraft such as the Piper Malibu involved in the crash produce high levels of carbon monoxide, the interim report said.

The gas is normally conveyed away from the aircraft through the exhaust system but poor sealing or leaks into the heating and ventilation system can enable it to enter the cabin.

The AAIB said it was working with the aircraft and engine manufacturers and the National Transportation Safety Board in the US ‘to identify possible pathways through which CO (carbon monoxide) might enter the cabin of this type of aircraft’.

"Work is also continuing to investigate pertinent operational, technical, organisational and human factors which might have contributed to the accident," they said.

A spokesman for Cardiff City said the club was ‘concerned’ at the AAIB's latest report as it ‘once again highlights that the aircraft used for Emiliano Sala was not appropriate’.

He added that ‘those who were instrumental in arranging its usage’ should be held to account.

Several devices are available to alert pilots over the presence of carbon monoxide.

The AAIB said they are not mandatory but can ‘alert pilots or passengers to a potentially deadly threat’.

Sala's family called for the wreckage to be salvaged to enable a ‘detailed technical examination of the plane’ to be carried out.

But an AAIB spokesman said it has decided not to carry out a repeat attempt due to the high costs involved, the information already collected and the risk that the wreckage would ‘not yield definitive evidence’ due to the plane's violent impact with the sea.

He added: "We will identify the correct safety issues through other means."

Investigators have previously said the validity of Mr Ibbotson's licence will form a key part of their inquiry.

The type of licence he held meant he could only fly passengers in the European Union on a cost-sharing basis, rather than for commercial flights.

A full accident report is expected to be published next year.