Tree campaigners defend actions after dispute with Sheffield residents

Maple Grove in Handsworth
Maple Grove in Handsworth
Have your say

Sheffield tree campaigners have defended their protests after they were criticised by residents who support the city council's felling.

People living in Maple Grove, Handsworth, last week said they were happy to see several trees in their street cut down and replaced.

One of the trees due to be felled.

One of the trees due to be felled.

Residents said the large trees were causing a number of problems, such as damaging the pavement. And they accused tree campaigners of failing to listen to their views.

But members of Sheffield Tree Action Groups, or Stag, said most of the trees in Maple Grove and other areas where they have been campaigning did not need replacing.

They accused the council and its partner in the Streets Ahead programme, Amey, of felling healthy street trees for no reason.

Paul Brooke, who was part of the protest in Maple Grove on Friday, said campaigners had been there lawfully, adding: "The last thing we as campaigners want to do is cause upset to local residents.

Residents say some trees are damaging the pavements.

Residents say some trees are damaging the pavements.

“The council and Amey are not removing these trees out of any concern for the views of, or the health and wellbeing of local residents.

"We accept that some trees will need to be replaced and if the trees on Maple Grove needed to be replaced as part of a proper urban tree strategy I would not be preventing it.”

A Stag spokesman pointed to the council's guidance on removing trees, which says issues highlighted by residents such as falling leaves or sap do not justify felling.

The spokesman said the damage to pavements in Maple Grove was 'minor' and could be fixed without removing trees.

Some trees have already been felled.

Some trees have already been felled.

Stag also said residents' concerns about fallen leaves should be dealt with by Amey through street sweeping.

But campaigners have failed to convince some residents.

Margaret Gough, who lives in Willow Drive, parallel to Maple Grove, said roads and pavements had been 'badly damaged' by trees which should 'all be taken down'.

"I have a tree directly outside my house and this has caused major damage on more than one occasion to my drive and the sewer pipes underneath," she said, adding that protesters should 'keep their noses out of it and let Amey get on with the job in hand'.

Today’s top stories:

Plea for extra security after series of thefts of sentimental items from Sheffield cemeteries

Teenager, 15, seriously injured after being hit by bus in Sheffield

Murder suspect due in court over death of South Yorkshire man

VIDEO/PHOTOS: Hundreds of bikers pay respect on last ride of Sheffield man Sam

'We want trees to come down - so why aren't protesters listening?'

Sheffield hospital bosses apologise after woman loses ovary in surgery error

Call for street patrols on Sheffield estate after masked gunman bursts into home with children inside

Gary Hooper injured! Sheffield Wednesday hit by potential play-off blow

Sheffield United: Ched Evans move to Blades nears completion

Download The Star's mobile app now for FREE