Unauthorised Sheffield car park owned by Elmsdale Estates closes after city council enforcement

A car park run without permission for years has closed after Sheffield City Council took enforcement action.

Fencing and signs have appeared at the Sylvester Gardens site in the Cultural Industries Quarter near Decathlon

It is owned by Elmsdale Estates, of Broomgrove Road, Broomhall, and has been used as a car park without permission since at least 2022.

Elmsdale Estates ran the Sylvester Gardens car park for years without permission.placeholder image
Elmsdale Estates ran the Sylvester Gardens car park for years without permission. | im

The firm applied for planning permission in January 2024, but it was refused because it would conflict with the council’s sustainable transport ambitions, undermine air quality and ‘disincentivise’ redevelopment.

When it failed to close the site, Sheffield City Council issued an enforcement notice.

Elmsdale appealed to the government’s Planning Inspectorate but the appeal was dismissed in January.

Elmsdale Estates' Sylvester Gardens car park was run by Bank Park.placeholder image
Elmsdale Estates' Sylvester Gardens car park was run by Bank Park. | nw

The company was contacted for comment.

It is the second car park to close after the city council launched a crackdown on rogue sites last summer.

In November, NCP left an unauthorised site on the corner of Fitzwilliam and Milton streets in the city centre after the city council refused two planning applications and launched enforcement action.

In July last year, Councillor Ben Miskell, chair of the transport, regeneration and climate policy committee, said operating without planning permission was “not acceptable.”

He said then: “These illegal sites can block future development on brownfield land and have a detrimental impact on local communities.”

He also urged people to report cowboy operators.

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice