Sheffield traffic: Readers debate the return of traffic to The Moor to help city centre

Popular opinion has it that road changes over the years have ‘killed’ Sheffield city centre - but do people want the return of traffic to pedestrianised streets?

Many readers complain that road closures coincide with a decline in the number of city centre shops since their heyday in the 1970s.

Most notably, cars were banned from The Moor and Fargate in the 1970s, with Tudor Square following in 1991.

The trend continues today with Sheffield City Council turning Pinstone and Surrey streets into bike lanes, with Cambridge Street to follow.

Debate has raged about the impact of traffic bans on Sheffield city centre, including on The Moorplaceholder image
Debate has raged about the impact of traffic bans on Sheffield city centre, including on The Moor | nw

But do people still want to see the return of traffic?

On our Facebook page, there was little support for the suggestion.

Lindsay Rogers said: “If we had vehicles back on The Moor, there would be no market stalls, no places to sit and rest. No freedom to walk leisurely down and no safety.

Two Sheffield Connect buses serve the city centre.placeholder image
Two Sheffield Connect buses serve the city centre. | nw

“It's lovely to be able to see the children do that and with access to Pound Park. Can you imagine the exhaust fumes?

“Buses stop round the back of Debenhams, Atkinsons and on Cumberland Street.”

Paul Campbell said: “I doubt that after the council spending so much money on the moor etc its going to go back to how it was in the 1970s, same with most of the city centre, it's not going to go back.”

Chris Eyre suggested electric vehicles to improve accessibility.

The trend continues today with Pinstone Street being turned into a bike lane.placeholder image
The trend continues today with Pinstone Street being turned into a bike lane. | nw

“A few small electric vehicles, say 12-seater, even if open sided, would solve the problem for elders and disabled without causing pollution and would make the city centre accessible to all.”

Others pointed out two Sheffield Connect free bus services already serve the city centre.

Julie Dean said: “There are free buses, the SC1 and SC2, that go all round town. They stop on the bottom of The Moor quite near the markets. I sometimes get the bus outside the Cathedral and drop off at the back of Atkinson.

“On the way back I getoff on Paternoster Row or Pond Street. Depends if it’s SC1 or SC2.

“They have loads of stops.”

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice