From hilltop suburbs with sweeping city views to leafy village-like corners on the edge of the Peak District, Sheffield has no shortage of great places to call home.
We asked the readers of The Star where they think the best spots are to live, and they didn’t hold back.
Some honourable mentions that did not make the list include:
Endcliffe: Loved by locals like Vron Oates, this area is green, peaceful and close to Ecclesall Road and the park.
High Green: Mentioned by Azubike Okani – a quiet northern suburb with easy access to open space.
Heeley: Rachel O’Brien praised this up-and-coming area for its community feel and proximity to the city.
Sheffield’s charm lies in its variety. Whether you want parks, pubs, peace, or Peak District paths, there’s a neighbourhood that’ll feel just right.
As Mark Davenport commented, “People will like where they grew up - a lot of people don’t move very far.”
And in Sheffield, that’s a pretty easy decision to make.
Here are some of the top picks from Sheffielders themselves.

5. Millhouses - Park life and riverside charm
Barbara Murphy has fond memories of growing up in this leafy suburb. “Millhouses is where I grew up. Loved it.” The area is well-loved for its large park, river walks, and excellent schools – making it a long-time favourite for families. | Dean Atkins

6. Dore and Totley - Gateway to the Peaks
Paul Savage didn’t hesitate to name “Dore and Totley” as his top pick. These southern suburbs sit right on the edge of the Peak District and offer beautiful homes, top schools, and a true village feel. It’s perfect for those looking for countryside living within city limits. | Dean Atkins/ National World Photo: Dean Atkins/ National World

7. S12 – Practical and picturesque
Debra Michelle Kelly shared a well-rounded view of living in S12, saying, “Open countryside on the doorstep and high up, no danger of flooding. Also on the tram link to town or Crystal Peaks, so easy access to shops. Near the M1 too.” The area is often overlooked, but offers excellent value and accessibility. | Google Photo: Google

8. Beighton - “Far enough away… close enough to the Peaks.”
Adrian Robinson nailed the appeal of Beighton: “Far enough away from’t centre; close enough t’t countryside, Peaks, n many pubs!” With a mix of new builds and traditional homes, Beighton strikes a great balance between city and village life. | Google

