Breaking

Suspended Sheffield Reform councillor breaks silence after controversy saying ‘I’m not apologising for jokes’

Suspended Reform councillor breaks silence after controversial social media posts revealed

A newly-elected Reform UK councillor in Sheffield suspended by the party last week over alleged Nazi sympathies and far-right social media posts has defended his posts as jokes made “after one too many pints”.

Councillor Nathaniel Mendayplaceholder image
Councillor Nathaniel Menday | LDRS/Reform

Nathaniel Menday, who won the Woodhouse ward seat on Sheffield City Council earlier this month, also admitted in his statement that he had previously “flirted with what could reasonably be referred to as far-right ideology”.

Other posts reportedly praised dictatorships, referenced eugenics and included Nazi imagery and references to Adolf Hitler.

Reform UK said Mr Menday had been suspended after he failed to declare social media posts.

A party spokesperson said: “Reform UK does not support such comments.”

In a statement published online today following his suspension, Mr Menday said he was now considering his political future.

He wrote: “There's obviously been a lot said about me and with all the press scrutiny (to be polite) I'm naturally considering my future.

“I wanted to get into politics to make a positive contribution to this city and country instead of just moaning on the internet.

“The question remains in my mind over whether it might be too much for myself and my family and whether, with this and my status as an independent, I will be able to carry out my duties to a standard that I would be happy with.

“I would have liked to have hit the ground running, but with the situation being as it is I'm going to need time to contemplate my own future... so I will be putting some distance between myself and this for a few weeks, specifically a few thousand miles.”

Menday outlined the work he has done in days following his election.

He said: “That being said, I don't want to be completely useless and I haven't been so far.

“I have raised a couple of issues with Amey and I did my best to play a leading role within Reform in regards to their motion for Thursday's council meeting,

“I hope my suggestion around amending the current Sheffield housing plan to build at a higher density in order to protect the greenbelt is reflected in their motion.

“Once I have my email, that will be in my bio and on the council website, so you can contact me with any genuine concerns.”

Mr Menday then addressed his social media posts, arguing websites used to recover deleted posts “should be illegal”.

“Using dubious websites to find deleted tweets is wrong and frankly I think these websites should be illegal,” he said.

“For older readers this may not be as much of an issue but for people growing up in the social media age there's something very scary about your adversaries being able to use every social media post you have ever made against you - even if you posted it in anger or after one too many pints, and proceeded to delete it soon after.”

Menday refused to apologise for what he referred to as jokes.

He said: “There are of course things I’ve said in the heat of the moment that I shouldn’t have said, or should have worded better, and I regret that - I'm sure we've all been there?

“But I'm not apologising for tweets that have been deleted because ultimately what more can I do?

“Likewise, I'm not apologising for jokes or memes.”

Addressing posts linked to Nazi imagery and references, he claimed much of the content was intended as “tongue in cheek”.

“When I talk about jokes, memes, or posts that were meant as tongue in cheek, I’m referring overwhelmingly to so-called Nazi related content,” he wrote.

“I like to make jokes about taboo topics as a lot of normal young lads do and there's nothing more subversive than jokes about this, without being directly hateful at least, which I try not to do.

“The entire Western, particularly English speaking, World is fundamentally paranoid about Nazi's under the bed: they stifle our public discourse by labelling anyone with views to the right of Ed Davey as being the second coming of Hitler and it's so tiresome.

“So when I've joked about this, it's often in a knowing, self deprecating way, as someone who has been called a Nazi on social media for voicing opinions that would be seen as perfectly mainstream in most of Europe.”

Mr Menday denied being a Nazi, as well as accusations of anti-semitism.

He said: “So am I a Nazi? No, of course not.

“My overriding principle is that all human beings have an inherent dignity and whatever else I believe comes second to this.

“I am a believer in objective morality. Any regime that would willingly murder millions of innocent people for no good reason is evil, whether that be the Nazi's or any of the other inhumane regimes of the last century.

“But let me take this opportunity to make a challenge to Sheffield City Council. Why is it that when I walk through town I see a poster with a hammer and sickle on many bins and bus stops?

“How is this acceptable when there would rightly be outrage if a Fascist symbol appeared in the same context?

“I also was called anti-semitic which I take particular issue with.

“I am not afraid to criticise any group but it's curious that none of my tweets included where I defended Israel's right to not only exist within its current borders but also to defend itself against aggression from Hamas.

“I also believe that the current Israeli regime has gone too far with their actions in Gaza, I am against land seizures in the West Bank, but I would happily call myself a Zionist at a time when a great number of people in Sheffield town hall would love nothing more than the destruction of Israel and yet they don't seem to get half as much scrutiny. “

The councillor also admitted that he had flirted with ‘more radical ways of thinking’ in the past.

“I will proudly call myself Right-Wing and I'll even admit to having flirted with more radical ways of thinking - but when push comes to shove I reject any ideology that would target people simply because of who they are.

“I am not prejudiced, and I think the people who know me know this,

“I believe in treating people as individuals before all else and if I continue as councillor no matter your background I will do my best for you if you come to me.”

News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice