Sheffield United: You've seen Transfermarkt's 'valuations' of Blades stars... here's how much our man thinks they're worth

Stats website Transfermarkt's 'valuations' of Sheffield United's stars has caused some debate this morning - so we thought we'd have a go ourselves.

'Market value' can be a highly subjective thing, so we tasked one of our writers to put his thinking cap on (or his tin hat). The results, it's fair to say, came out quite differently. Let us know what you think in the comments below, or on Twitter. (Valuations are in GBP)

United's Bramall Lane. (Richard Markham Photography)placeholder image
United's Bramall Lane. (Richard Markham Photography)
Transfermarkt (TM): 900,000 - Danny Hall (DH): 10m.
One of English football's brightest goalkeepers, owned by Manchester United - who aren't short of a few quid, eitherplaceholder image
Transfermarkt (TM): 900,000 - Danny Hall (DH): 10m. One of English football's brightest goalkeepers, owned by Manchester United - who aren't short of a few quid, either
TM: 675,000. DH: 4m.
Young, quick, talented, hungry. Fits the system at United so well - and can only get better.placeholder image
TM: 675,000. DH: 4m. Young, quick, talented, hungry. Fits the system at United so well - and can only get better.
TM: 675,000. DH: 5m.
Shown his class this season in that left wing-back role. Are there many better than him in this league? A full Republic of Ireland international, too. 675,000 is an insult.placeholder image
TM: 675,000. DH: 5m. Shown his class this season in that left wing-back role. Are there many better than him in this league? A full Republic of Ireland international, too. 675,000 is an insult.
TM: 1.35m. DH: 8m
Anything less than, say, 6m I wouldn't even entertain.placeholder image
TM: 1.35m. DH: 8m Anything less than, say, 6m I wouldn't even entertain.
TM: 4.5m. DH: 8-10m.
Transfermarkt's 4.5m seems very low, especially given a bid of more than that was rejected for O'Connell in the summer. Who could replace him, especially given his role in United's system?placeholder image
TM: 4.5m. DH: 8-10m. Transfermarkt's 4.5m seems very low, especially given a bid of more than that was rejected for O'Connell in the summer. Who could replace him, especially given his role in United's system?
TM 450,000 DH 4m
Another player who is indispensable in United's system. Someone with all of Basham's attributes wouldn't come cheap if United were looking to sign him, hence my high valuationplaceholder image
TM 450,000 DH 4m Another player who is indispensable in United's system. Someone with all of Basham's attributes wouldn't come cheap if United were looking to sign him, hence my high valuation
TM 675,000. DH 2m
Cost more than 675,000 when he signed from Oxford, and has since had two years of experience in the Championship under his belt.placeholder image
TM 675,000. DH 2m Cost more than 675,000 when he signed from Oxford, and has since had two years of experience in the Championship under his belt.
TM 2.7m, DH 5m
Dowell is highly-rated at Everton so can you imagine him leaving for under 3m, given the premium placed on English players? Me either.placeholder image
TM 2.7m, DH 5m Dowell is highly-rated at Everton so can you imagine him leaving for under 3m, given the premium placed on English players? Me either.
TM 360,000, DH 3m
Assuming he signs a new deal, Coutts remains a vital member of a squad pushing for the Premier Leagueplaceholder image
TM 360,000, DH 3m Assuming he signs a new deal, Coutts remains a vital member of a squad pushing for the Premier League
TM 180,000, DH 500,000
A great servant to United, Wright has dropped down the pecking order at United but would be a superb buy for any club at this priceplaceholder image
TM 180,000, DH 500,000 A great servant to United, Wright has dropped down the pecking order at United but would be a superb buy for any club at this price
TM 3.6m, DH 7m
Again Transfermarkt reckon Egan has depreciated in value, which anyone who's watched him this season will surely disagree with...placeholder image
TM 3.6m, DH 7m Again Transfermarkt reckon Egan has depreciated in value, which anyone who's watched him this season will surely disagree with...
TM 900k, DH 5m
In reality Sharp is priceless to United but, taking emotion out of it, a 16-goal striker in the Championship shouldn't come cheap. Age may count against him a littleplaceholder image
TM 900k, DH 5m In reality Sharp is priceless to United but, taking emotion out of it, a 16-goal striker in the Championship shouldn't come cheap. Age may count against him a little
TM 3.6m DH 4m
Cost Cardiff 6m a year ago, with January signings notoriously inflated in priceplaceholder image
TM 3.6m DH 4m Cost Cardiff 6m a year ago, with January signings notoriously inflated in price
TM 675,000, DH 3m.
Scored 18 goals in the Championship last season and is still a vital part of the squad at Bramall Lane.placeholder image
TM 675,000, DH 3m. Scored 18 goals in the Championship last season and is still a vital part of the squad at Bramall Lane.
TM 2.7m, DH 6m
Again, so important to the way United play. A 50-cap international midfielder, right up there with the best in the second tier.placeholder image
TM 2.7m, DH 6m Again, so important to the way United play. A 50-cap international midfielder, right up there with the best in the second tier.
TM 900,000, DH 3m
Again assuming he signs a new deal at United, McGoldrick has shown why Leicester bid 5m for him in 2014 with ten goals this seasonplaceholder image
TM 900,000, DH 3m Again assuming he signs a new deal at United, McGoldrick has shown why Leicester bid 5m for him in 2014 with ten goals this season
TM 675,000 DH 2.5m
Another full international undervalued by Transfermarktplaceholder image
TM 675,000 DH 2.5m Another full international undervalued by Transfermarkt
TM 900,000 DH 2m
Stearman has seen and done it in his career and that level of experience can be priceless for United as they attempt to win promotion.placeholder image
TM 900,000 DH 2m Stearman has seen and done it in his career and that level of experience can be priceless for United as they attempt to win promotion.
TM 225,000 DH 2m+
Appearances have been limited so far but has good pedigree, and why would United do business at just over 200,000?placeholder image
TM 225,000 DH 2m+ Appearances have been limited so far but has good pedigree, and why would United do business at just over 200,000?
TM 450,000, DH 4m
Another one who doesn't have age on his side, but Duffy is so integral to the way United play - hence the valuationplaceholder image
TM 450,000, DH 4m Another one who doesn't have age on his side, but Duffy is so integral to the way United play - hence the valuation
TM 1.35m DH 500,000
One of the rare instances where Transfermarkt have gone a little high, based on Johnson's fleeting appearances so farplaceholder image
TM 1.35m DH 500,000 One of the rare instances where Transfermarkt have gone a little high, based on Johnson's fleeting appearances so far
TM 450,000 DH 2.5m+
A 'keeper who would more than hold his own at Championship level, for meplaceholder image
TM 450,000 DH 2.5m+ A 'keeper who would more than hold his own at Championship level, for me
TM 450,000, DH 750,000
Valuable experience and cover for Chris Bashamplaceholder image
TM 450,000, DH 750,000 Valuable experience and cover for Chris Basham
TM 1.35m, DH 1m.
Another restricted to a handful of appearances but has shown he's a worthy member of United's squadplaceholder image
TM 1.35m, DH 1m. Another restricted to a handful of appearances but has shown he's a worthy member of United's squad
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice