Sheffield gardeners fear precious allotments will be left a 'wasteland' after Yorkshire Water sewage project
Tenants on a Sheffield allotment fear they will be left with nothing in the wake of a 18-month-long Yorkshire Water sewage project.
Members of the Brushes Allotments and the Friends of Firth Park Community Allotments charity, in Vickers Road, will be kicked off the site on February 2 and locked out until 2028.


Yorkshire Water is moving in to build an 17-metre-deep storm water overflow tank and pumping station in a £3.2m scheme to combat sewage discharging into a nearby stream during heavy rain.
However, ahead of the move out date, residents are bitter at what the work stands to do to the allotment site, the destruction of their treasured gardens and sheds, and a “slap in the face” compensation offer of £2,000 per plot.
“I fear there will be nothing left of 20 years of history,” said Firth Park Community Allotment member Claudia Kuntze, 63.
“Yorkshire Water are saying it will be ‘as good if not better’ but we don’t believe it.
“The allotment and the community workshops are a lifeline to many that will be gone for 18 months, and when we come back we will have to start from zero.
“I believe it will be a wasteland, levelled with soil that will wash away in heavy rain.
“I don’t know if I have the energy to start again.”


Yorkshire Water approached the allotment plot landowner, Sheffield City Council, in August 2025 and served notice for tenants in October. It is understood neighbouring residents on Vickers Road and others were not contacted.
The work will expand an existing system at the north end of the site to add a new ‘combined sewer overflow’ storage tank to reduce sewage entering the nearby stream during heavy rain.
Yorkshire Water says it will return the site in a “much improved condition.”
But tenants say they have no faith in this, with gardens, hedges, fences, sheds, children’s reading areas, greenhouses, and mature plants like rose buses all expected to vanish.


Additionally, tenants were initially asked to write itemised lists of what they stood to lose in the project after they were promised personalised compensation claims.
However, residents were then told in an email sent in January this would no longer be the case, and they would instead receive a flat £1,500 per plot if they opted to leave the allotment for another site, or £2,000 if they stayed.
This means the charity - which holds a Yorkshire in Bloom Award, a Green Flag Award and won the Best Allotment in Sheffield Award twice - will be compensated only £6,000. Their plot features a large polytunnel valued at £10,000 alone.
One tenant, who asked not to be named, told The Star they spent months in late 2025 clearing away “waist-high weeds” and building a fence and gateway for their allotment - not knowing they were wasting their time as it would be “flattened” in the new year.
Claudia said: “Ordinarily in January, we would be preparing for the next year of growing, fixing fences, cutting back overgrowth, and getting ready to welcome back classes and volunteer groups. Instead we are deciding what can we get off the site in time.
“I hope when we are allowed back on we will have many volunteers out to get things back on track.”
Yorkshire Water statement
The Star contacted Yorkshire Water to ask why the compensation offer was changed and what amenities specifically will be put in place for residents when work ends in 18 months.
A Yorkshire Water spokesperson said: “Temporarily moving the allotment tenants is not an easy decision to take and we understand how important allotment spaces are, providing health and wellbeing benefits, as well as the joy of gardening and growing your own fresh produce. The important £3.2m project we will be carrying out at the site of the existing combined sewer overflow (CSO) in the coming months is to reduce storm overflows into Firth Park stream.
“We’ve been working closely with Sheffield Council, Friends of Firth Park community charity and allotment tenants since October to support them with assistance and funding to help move tenants onto temporary pitches at nearby allotment sites for those who want them. We’re working together to find safe and suitable storage for equipment and garden tools for those tenants who have decided not to move, so that it can be safely returned to their allotment plot once the work is completed.
“A number of the plots are currently overgrown, and together with our contract partners Ward & Burke, we’ll be working with the local authority to clear these so that more spaces are available for tenants once the construction work is complete. We’re also providing other betterment activity such as new fencing, materials and planting native species, when we hand the site back.
“We want to make this temporary transition as smooth as possible. Tenants will receive compensation for their plots, as well as the offer for a temporary space and we are working with the Charity to ensure it can continue its great community work, in a bigger and better allotment space, once the investment and construction is complete.
“While we appreciate that this is hugely inconvenient for tenants, of the several options that were considered, Bushes allotment at Vickers Road was identified as the location that would create the lowest level of disruption for the local community during construction. As the location of the existing CSO, it was also identified as the site delivering the most benefit (90 per cent reduction of storm discharges into Firth Park Stream) while providing the best value for money to our customers.
“Our agents are on hand to negotiate any specialist items, by exception, with the tenants (and the Charity) if they feel that the compensation is not as expected and they can provide relevant paperwork so that they can be fairly compensated during the temporary move.”
