Star readers' reaction to school smartphones ban reflects clashing parent and school priorities

Star readers react to ban on phones on school premises

Star readers have reacted to plans for a ban on smartphones in schools - reflecting conflicting needs for child and parent contact and preventing distraction.

A ban on mobile phones in schools has been announcedplaceholder image
A ban on mobile phones in schools has been announced | Submit

In around half of the 300 comments posted on The Star’s Facebook yesterday when the news was announced, parents spoke about “safety” and the need to “track” their children’s whereabouts while travelling to and from school.

Although many schools in the city have already introduced “no see, no hear” policies, only one - Forge Valley - had brought in a total ban on its premises.

Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson urged schools earlier this year to follow new guidance that schools be phone-free for the entire day.

However the government is now set table an amendment to its Children's Wellbeing and Schools Bill, creating a clear legal requirement for schools on the matter.

Data shows around 80 per cent of schools allow phones to be kept in bags as part of the “no see, no hear” policy.

However research by the University of the West of England showed this does not prevent pupils from using phones during the school day.

But Star reader comments reveal a strong push back against a total ban on premises, should that become the norm.

Staci Jordan’s said her child had to catch two buses to school with an hour-long journey each way, she added: “Yes, I agree turn it off in school but he needs it with him before and after as I have him tracked on it.”

Lou Becs wrote: “I agree they don't need access when in classes, agreed. However my 12-year-old makes his own way to school and back on public transport and the only thing that keeps me from worrying sick is the fact I can see where he is, and be able to check he's ok.

“He has had issues in the past with other kids after school and needs to be able to contact us.”

Amy Wild said her phone was “a saviour” at school.

She said; “Without having my phone I would have been stuck in horrible situations at school - when my son goes to secondary he will have a phone whether they like it or not. Agree to disagree.”

Many of those leaving comments in support of the ban failed to address the safety while travelling issue, suggesting contact with parents via the school office.

Julie Watkins wrote: “No need for phones during school time. If an emergency happens the school will contact parents like they have always done.”

Leighton Alexander Duvall was unequivocal in his support, saying: “Yes, 100 per cent - no kid in school needs access to a phone...none.”

Graham Tilly said: “As long as parents have the school contact number if they need to get a message to their child or children, mobiles should be banned.”

It is worth pointing out that some schools operate a locking policy - in which phones are handed in at the start of the school day or stored locked on their person with third-party access only - for example in Yondr pouches.

This method allows their use during travel. Several readers spoke about this.

Kay Pearcey said: “My son’s school have the Yondr pouches so they keep their phones with them all day, lock the pouch in a morning and unlock it as they leave.”

Reflecting what has been pointed out as unclear messaging on what a ban would actually mean, some commentors were in support of the “no see, no hear” policy.

Carole Overall wrote: “I don’t think they should be allowed in lessons but parents quite rightly need to know or track their children until they are safe as when I was young 70 years ago without phones it was much safer than it is today.”

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1887
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice